READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Burnham to tell City dinner Brexit 'has not worked' days before Friday EU summit

Burnham to tell City dinner Brexit 'has not worked' days before Friday EU summit
Prime Minister Andy Burnham is set to say tonight, Nov. 16, that the UK has 'lost more than we gained' from Brexit, then sign food, emissions-trading and youth-mobility deals with the EU in Brussels on Friday, Nov. 20. Whether the agreements stay inside Labour's red lines, and what alignment with EU rules costs in sovereignty, is still to be settled.

Andy Burnham will use a speech at the Lord Mayor's Banquet in the City of London tonight, Monday, Nov. 16, to declare that Brexit "has not worked." According to advance excerpts from his office, he will say: "The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained."

The speech comes four days before a UK-EU summit in Brussels on Friday, Nov. 20, with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and European Council President Antonio Costa. It was originally scheduled for July and was postponed when Keir Starmer resigned. Burnham took office that month.

What Burnham will say

Burnham will compare the post-2016 settlement negotiated by Boris Johnson's government to "the Emperor's New Clothes," where "no one is prepared to say the obvious truth." His line: "the emperor has nothing on."

He will argue that Johnson's promise to take back control was not delivered and that Britain ended up with a needlessly hard Brexit that put up barriers for businesses. The same message came out of his Saturday address to the Welsh Labour conference, where he said the UK had "lost more than we gained."

He will describe the new deals as "a win-win" and a "new approach. Not adversarial. No longer burning bridges." He says the agreements could lift GDP by 0.4%, roughly £17bn.

Three deals, three tests

The package has three main parts: cutting red tape for food and farm exports, linking the UK and EU emissions-trading schemes, and a youth mobility scheme. A senior EU diplomat told AFP the three deals appeared largely wrapped up. Officials are still arguing over how they fit together in the summit text.

Burnham will say he signs only if an agreement passes three tests:

  • It is consistent with Labour's manifesto and the government's red lines.
  • It improves the Brexit deal and moves it closer to what people thought they were voting for in 2016.
  • It passes what he calls the "Makerfield test" by delivering tangible improvements in people's everyday lives.

The red lines come from Labour's 2024 manifesto under Starmer: no return to the customs union, the single market or freedom of movement. They bind Labour until the next election, due in 2029. Burnham differs from Starmer in tone. He has floated the possibility that Britain could one day apply to rejoin and has said he will set out options for the long-term relationship around the time of the summit.

The sticking points

The accords were in the pipeline before Burnham moved into Downing Street. Officials in Brussels still describe the mood as upbeat, but hurdles remain. The biggest is the EU's demand that UK universities admit European students at reduced fees. Speaking in Dublin last week, Burnham said the requests are coming from the European side but that London is "putting our requests on the table too." He predicted talks would "go down to the wire."

An earlier draft summit statement seen by AFP would let young people from the EU and UK live in each other's territory for up to three years.

EU relations minister Hamish Falconer told the BBC on Sunday that the UK would get a "voice in the room" under a new deal but no vote on EU food policy. That is the price of alignment: Britain would follow rules it does not help write. Falconer also said there could be an "exit clause" in case a future UK government reversed the closer alignment. He said the EU is "worried" about a future Reform or Conservative government undoing the agreement. The BBC understands the clause reflects EU concern about the cost of rebuilding border food-safety check facilities installed after Brexit.

Johnson pushes back

Johnson, who resigned as prime minister in 2022 over Partygate, rejects Burnham's premise. He told the Telegraph that Britain would "absolutely" vote for Brexit again if Burnham forced another vote. "It is madness to escalate the Brexit issue as your political priority," he said. "He will impale himself and his party on this point, and he needs to move off it because he won't win – because the reality is that people are not fools."

Burnham has said voters would ultimately be "the boss" of any changes. He has not proposed a new referendum in the material surrounding tonight's speech.

Cars as a test case

Alignment has a cost beyond food rules. Writing in a commentary, columnist Ross Clark argues that if Burnham accepts "dynamic alignment" with EU regulation, Britain would almost certainly have to adopt EU electric vehicle targets. The UK's Zero Emission Vehicle mandate is stricter than the EU's. It requires 33% of new car sales to be pure electric in 2026, rising to 80% in 2030 and 100% by 2035, with fines of up to £12,000 per non-compliant vehicle. Clark cites 26.6% pure-electric sales so far this year and says the government is reportedly preparing to water the mandate down. He says Labour ministers who are both pro-EU and committed to Net Zero "are going to have to choose."

The mandate review is a separate process from the EU talks. No government decision has been announced linking the two.

What comes next

The three agreements are due to be signed in Brussels on Friday, Nov. 20. Open questions are whether the student-fee dispute is resolved, how the exit clause is worded, and whether Burnham's promised options paper on the longer-term relationship lands the same week.

Sources used for this briefing

7 links from 7 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center-left
HuffPost UKAndy Burnham Blasts Brexit And Says UK 'Lost More Than We Gained' By Quitting EU
center-left
nz.news.yahooBurnham hits out at Brexit failure as crunch EU summit looms
center-right
Jerusalem PostUK PM Burnham ready to confront 'obvious truth' of Brexit's costs | The Jerusalem Post
left
The GuardianAndy Burnham to say Brexit ‘has not worked’ and he will sign new deal with EU
right
BreitbartUK PM predicts talks will 'go down to wire' for EU summit deal
right
Epoch TimesNet Zero Is Falling Apart, One Target at a Time
unknown
Cedar NewsAndy Burnham to say Brexit ‘has not worked’ and he will sign new deal with EU | Cedar News