READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Russian Peace Paper Demands UK Drop Nuclear Cover for Europe, Pull NATO Back to 1997 Lines, per NYT

Russian Peace Paper Demands UK Drop Nuclear Cover for Europe, Pull NATO Back to 1997 Lines, per NYT
A Russian document dated Nov. 10, obtained by The New York Times from a person involved in the talks, lays out conditions that include ending British and French nuclear protection of other European states and withdrawing NATO forces to 1997 positions. UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham and Finland's defense minister rejected the demands outright. Zelensky says Washington floated Ukraine joining NATO in exchange for leaving Donbas, and the five European delegations meant to join the talks have yet to sit down with Moscow.

The written terms behind Moscow's position have now surfaced, along with a new account from Zelensky of what Washington has floated in return.

What the Russian paper says

The document is dated Nov. 10 and was obtained by The New York Times from a person involved in the negotiations. The Telegraph has also reported on its contents. It sets out conditions Russia wants met before it agrees to end the war.

According to the paper, NATO would withdraw from Eastern Europe and the Baltic states and pull its forces back to the positions it held in 1997. Finland would leave the alliance. NATO would commit to sending no troops to Ukraine. All Western weapons and military equipment deliveries to Kyiv would stop, and Ukraine would be barred from joining NATO.

The most pointed demand targets Britain. The paper asks the UK, and France, to rule out using their nuclear weapons to protect other European countries.

In exchange, Russia would let Ukraine seek EU membership, provided Kyiv stays out of the bloc's common defense arrangements. Under the terms as reported, Russia would also keep the Ukrainian territory it occupies.

Much of this repeats what the Kremlin demanded in December 2021, two months before the full-scale invasion in February 2022. Then, as now, Moscow wanted NATO rolled back and a halt to eastward expansion.

Europe says no

Burnham responded after meeting European leaders in Dublin. "That's not up for negotiation. It's for Europe to decide its own arrangements, Europe and Europe alone," he said.

He also said there was a "very strong feeling" among the leaders that Russian attempts to bring Europe's security architecture into the talks could not be accepted.

Finnish Defense Minister Antti Häkkänen was blunter about the demand that Finland leave NATO. "Such matters are in no way a matter for negotiation. Russia knows that. This is absolutely outrageous to even suggest such a thing," he said.

The stakes are widest for countries that joined NATO after 1997, including Poland, Hungary, Romania and the Baltic states. A pullback to 1997 lines would remove allied forces from all of them.

Zelensky: Washington raised Donbas for NATO

In comments released Saturday, Zelensky said the Americans asked a question in Abu Dhabi that had not come up before: if Ukraine joined NATO, would it withdraw from Donbas? He described it as the first time the idea had been raised.

He read it as a signal. "After providing Ukraine with this kind of defence support, seeing this kind of development of our army and this strength in our defence, they cannot simply let Ukraine go," he said, adding that NATO is "back on the agenda."

NATO and Washington had not directly commented on his account when the remarks were released. Zelensky repeated that Ukraine will not recognize any land seized by Russian troops as Russian, and said Ukrainians will decide whether to accept any deal.

The two accounts sit far apart. Moscow's paper bars Ukraine from NATO. Zelensky says the Americans floated NATO membership as something Kyiv could trade territory for. Russia has long called Ukrainian membership a red line.

Washington's line

Kushner has not confirmed Zelensky's description. After the Abu Dhabi talks and separate meetings with Putin and Zelensky on Thursday, he posted on X that reported positions from both sides were "maximalist propositions" accompanied by strong political rhetoric.

He said the team is "determined to continue the hard work," will maintain confidentiality for sensitive negotiations, and that several new ideas from the discussions "are now being explored."

On the NATO side, retired Gen. Philip Breedlove, the former Supreme Allied Commander Europe, warned Fox News Digital that Putin has long pushed a three-sphere vision: China in the Far East, Russia in Europe, America in the Western Hemisphere. "I do not expect there's going to be a lot of cooperation from the countries of Europe," he said.

Trump has described a coming agreement as "a big, beautiful agreement" that could involve "all of Europe." The Nov. 10 paper shows what Moscow's side has put in writing on European security.

Europe gets a seat

EU leaders agreed on Nov. 13 that the UK, France, Germany, Italy and Poland will represent Europe in any Russia-Ukraine talks. Putin is believed to have agreed to let them join, which the American mediators see as key to ending the war.

The fighting has not paused. Russia struck the eastern city of Pavlohrad and a village near Zaporizhzhia on Saturday, and Zelensky warned that the Kremlin is betting everything on this winter's campaign.

It is unclear whether the Nov. 10 paper is Russia's opening position or its floor, and whether the five European delegations will be in the room when it is put on the table.

Sources used for this briefing

6 links from 6 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

right
BreitbartUS suggested Kyiv cede land to Russia in exchange for joining NATO, Zelensky says
right
Fox NewsTrump’s proposed Russia deal raises NATO alarm as ex-commander warns Putin seeks influence over Europe
right
ExpressFurious Putin delivers UK huge ultimatum in shock new papers
unknown
European InterestPutin's unrealistic conditions to end Ukraine's war
unknown
Ukrainian News Network (UNN)Putin issued an ultimatum to the United Kingdom: it concerns nuclear weapons and Ukraine - The Telegraph
unknown
Euromaidan PressRussia demands Britain stop shielding the rest of Europe with its nuclear deterrent as a price for peace in Ukraine — Telegraph