READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Minister admits government cannot put a cost on fixing England's failing maternity units

Minister admits government cannot put a cost on fixing England's failing maternity units
NHS minister Karin Smyth conceded in written parliamentary answers that the Department of Health cannot say what it would cost to repair or replace maternity units NHS England says are at risk of breakdown. NHS England has said 43% of maternity and neonatal units fail basic safety standards, and the maintenance backlog across the NHS stands at £17.3 billion.

The government does not know what it would cost to fix England's worst maternity units. It has now said so in writing.

Karin Smyth, the NHS minister at the Department of Health and Social Care, told Parliament the department could not put a figure on upgrading maternity and neonatal units that NHS England believes need significant repair or replacement soon, or that face a "serious risk of imminent breakdown." She was answering written questions from Helen Morgan, the Liberal Democrats' health spokesperson.

The warnings are already on the record

NHS England said in September 2025 that poor infrastructure meant 43% of maternity and neonatal units did not meet basic safety standards. Over the previous three years, staff logged 14,519 incidents in which the physical condition of premises interrupted or affected clinical care, according to NHS England.

The Care Quality Commission warned in 2024 of "serious safety risks" from cramped space, ageing buildings and a shortage of operating theatres. NHS England has also said power supply problems and faulty nurse call systems add pressure on staff and can delay procedures, including planned caesarean sections.

Morgan did not soften her reaction. "NHS England has spelt out in black and white just how serious this is, with dozens of maternity units falling apart and some at serious risk of imminent breakdown," she said. "Ministers are gambling with the safety of mothers, babies and NHS staff caring for them."

That characterisation is Morgan's. The government has not accepted it.

What the buildings look like

Baroness Valerie Amos's review of maternity services this summer found Musgrove Park hospital's unit in Taunton, Somerset, "old and not designed to deliver 21st-century care," with "leaking roofs" and rooms often too hot or too cold. The antenatal ward is being held up with metal poles.

CQC inspectors found water had leaked into clinical areas and mould had formed on the walls and ceilings of the postnatal ward. They still rated the care staff delivered as good. Hospital bosses acknowledged in September that the unit is "old, outdated and cramped."

At Stepping Hill hospital in Stockport, Jules Wilkinson said he held a loose ceiling light in place for an hour while his wife gave birth to their daughter Cora. The fitting narrowly missed a midwife. Wilkinson described the 121-year-old hospital as "almost in a death spiral." The hospital's chief executive, Karen James, believes the trust needs £400 million to keep patients and staff safe. That figure covers the hospital as a whole, not just maternity.

Money going in, money coming out

The Department of Health points to what it has spent. It says it has allocated £271 million since April 2025 to projects addressing critical risks in maternity and neonatal facilities, and has announced more than £1.5 billion to improve NHS buildings and facilities.

The backlog is far larger. According to the Guardian, the latest official data put the cost of clearing the NHS's accumulated maintenance needs at £17.3 billion. The Guardian also reported that the latest budget cut the NHS capital budget by £1 billion over the next four years.

Those numbers sit awkwardly together. A government can fund repairs without a full price tag, and the £271 million is real money aimed at the most urgent risks. But it is hard to set a capital budget, or judge whether it is enough, without knowing what the job costs. That is ordinary budgeting, and it applies to any department spending taxpayer money.

No one has argued the buildings are fine. The dispute is over urgency and accountability. NHS England has already identified which units are at risk of imminent breakdown, so the units are known. The price of fixing them is not.

What comes next

The department has not said whether it will commission a national estimate for maternity estate repairs. Until it does, there is no way to compare the £271 million already allocated with what the worst units need. Stepping Hill's own £400 million request alone is larger than that national allocation, though it covers the whole hospital.

Sources used for this briefing

5 links from 4 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

left
The GuardianMinisters accused of ‘gambling with safety’ for not knowing cost of NHS maternity unit repairs
unknown
1stheadlines1stHeadlines
unknown
finwire.ioMinisters accused of ‘gambling with safety’ for not knowing cost of NHS maternity unit repairs
unknown
ua.newsUK government has not estimated maternity unit repair costs — The Guardian
unknown
Cedar NewsFormer residents raise concerns about response to Integra Vistas Apartment Fire in Hixson | Cedar News