READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Croatian Prosecutors Pursue Aggravated Murder Case After Patient Dies Restrained at Zagreb Psychiatric Hospital

Croatian Prosecutors Pursue Aggravated Murder Case After Patient Dies Restrained at Zagreb Psychiatric Hospital
Kristian Josip Periš, 32, died on Oct. 21 at the Sveti Ivan psychiatric clinic in Zagreb. Four medical technicians are in custody on suspicion of aggravated murder, and thousands protested Saturday. A state-run hospital with a doctor and several staff in the room is now the test of whether Croatia's oversight system holds anyone to account.

A 32-year-old man strapped to a hospital bed died in a Croatian public psychiatric clinic, and hospital cameras recorded it. Weeks later the video is driving large street protests across the country.

Kristian Josip Periš, a former national athlete, kinesiologist and para-sport coach, died on Oct. 21 at the Sveti Ivan (St. John) Psychiatric Clinic in the Jankomir district of Zagreb. According to the public prosecutor's office, he had been admitted with an acute mental disorder.

What the video shows

An eight-minute clip from the hospital's surveillance cameras was published by Croatian media in early November. It shows staff using force against a man whose arms and legs are strapped down. One staff member holds a pillow over his face.

Media accounts of the footage, cited by the European Network of (Ex-)Users and Survivors of Psychiatry, describe more than the pillow. They say pressure was applied to the pillow, neck and chest with knees, and that the man was struck in the chest with an elbow and fists, including after he appeared to stop resisting. Those accounts say seven or more staff members, including a doctor, were in the room and no one appears to have intervened.

Preliminary autopsy findings, as reported by the media, include multiple rib fractures, a fractured sternum, and swelling of the lungs and brain. The final cause of death has not been established.

The criminal case

On Nov. 8, the Zagreb District Prosecutor's Office announced a criminal investigation into four medical technicians at the hospital. Prosecutors say the staff used excessive physical force in breach of medical regulations and caused numerous bodily injuries, after which the patient died. The suspicion is aggravated murder of a vulnerable person.

A court ordered the four suspects held in custody. They are presumed innocent, and a court will determine criminal liability.

The case is widening. Prosecutors have expanded their inquiries to other staff who were present during the incident, according to reporting carried by The Independent. Al Jazeera reports that eight hospital workers have been arrested on murder charges. The four-person figure is the one tied to the prosecutor's announcement and the court's custody order.

The hospital's management has resigned since the footage emerged. Clinic director Maida Grach stepped down, as did her deputy, the nursing adviser and four of the seven members of the governing board.

Streets fill

On Saturday, Nov. 14, hundreds gathered in Zagreb's Flower Square for "Eight Minutes' Silence for Kristian Josip Periš," organized by the student initiative Time for Change. Organizers said the eight minutes symbolized the length of time the patient is believed to have been abused while restrained to a hospital bed. Similar gatherings took place in Split, Dubrovnik and Osijek.

On Saturday, Nov. 21, thousands filled Ban Jelačić Square holding candles and white pillows. Media reported about 1,000 people marching in Rijeka.

"I watched the video and I was in shock to see that evil," said Mirna Strugar, who attended the Zagreb protest. "I hope this will never be repeated."

Family lawyer Leon Zrnić said Periš "asked for help" at the clinic and died during the hospitalization. Zrnić said the video established that staff hit and strangled him, that he had broken ribs, and that "as a result of that illegal procedure, he lost his life." That is the family's lawyer's characterization. The court has yet to rule on it.

The family has set out demands including questioning of all staff who were present during the restraint, mandatory video recording of such procedures, retention of recordings for at least six months, and a ban on actions that may impair a patient's breathing.

Government and advocacy response

Health Minister Irena Hrstić said a preliminary investigation uncovered irregularities in the clinic's operations, including concerns about documentation of physical restraint and timely notification of authorities. The government says the hospital notified the ministry only on Nov. 7, even though the death occurred on Oct. 21.

Mental Health Europe, the European Disability Forum and the European Network of (Ex-)Users and Survivors of Psychiatry have all issued statements. They call for a swift, independent investigation that covers institutional oversight failures, not just the individuals in the room.

They also want more than prosecutions. The European Disability Forum is calling on Croatia and other European countries to phase out coercive measures and forced treatment in mental healthcare. It also wants a Council of Europe text it calls harmful withdrawn, saying the text would cement those practices across the continent.

Kristijan Grđan, a Croatian board member of the Forum representing Mental Health Europe, said Croatian disability advocates have warned that widespread use of these methods leads to abuse and death. "It's not even the first time it happened," he said. The Forum's statement does not cite earlier cases.

The ENUSP notes that most European countries have laws saying coercion should be used only as a "last resort." It argues that in practice coercive measures continue to be used systematically while alternatives are rarely developed. It cites a UN disability rights committee review of Spain that expressed concern about deaths of people with psychosocial disabilities during involuntary restraint.

What is at stake

The prosecution has to prove what happened and who was responsible. Aggravated murder is the most serious charge available, and the cause-of-death finding will matter to it.

The second question concerns a public institution. If a doctor and several staff were present and no one stopped it, as the media accounts of the footage describe, the failure is not limited to the people holding the pillow. That is a question about supervision, training and accountability at a taxpayer-funded hospital, and the answer will determine whether anyone above the technicians faces consequences.

Whether prosecutors formally charge more staff, and whether the final autopsy report fixes the cause of death, are the next developments to watch.

Sources used for this briefing

7 links from 7 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center-left
Al JazeeraCroatia outraged after psychiatric patient dies from alleged hospital abuse
left
The IndependentCroatia shocked by psychiatric hospital death as protestors demand justice
unknown
ukrmedia.newsIn Croatia, hundreds of people took to the streets to protest following the death of a patient
unknown
madinirelandStatement by European network of ex-users and survivors of psychiatry on the death of Kristian Josip Peris
unknown
inavukicA Brutal Act of Alleged Sadistic Violence Claims the Life of a Psychiatric Hospital Patient in Croatia
unknown
edf-fephDeath in a Croatian psychiatric hospital shows the horrifying consequences of use of coercion - European Disability Forum
unknown
mentalhealtheurope32-year old man dies following severe violence in Croatian psychiatric facility: MHE calls for justice and urgent action to end coercion