Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.
Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.
GAO: Labor Department Has No Private Equity Guidance for 401(k) Plans as Its Proposal Would Allow Them

The Labor Department has not told 401(k) plan sponsors or savers how private equity differs from the stocks and bonds that normally fill a retirement account. That is the finding of a Government Accountability Office report released publicly Nov. 10.
The gap matters because the department has a proposal pending that would explicitly permit alternative investments in retirement plans.
What the GAO found
GAO said little is known about how much private equity 401(k) plans currently hold. It also reviewed academic research on performance and found no consensus.
Some studies found private equity funds outperformed publicly traded stocks during the periods examined, though the size of the gains varied widely. Others found underperformance once risk or fees were accounted for. One study used benchmarks that left out a risk premium, the extra return some experts say private equity should deliver for taking on more risk.
GAO also found no agreed method for measuring private equity against public markets. That makes comparisons hard for the administrators who would have to pick these funds and the workers who would own them.
The agency analyzed federal and private financial data, research papers and SEC filings, and interviewed industry representatives, consumer advocates and officials from the U.S. and four other countries.
The pending Labor Department proposal
Under the DOL proposal, plan fiduciaries could include alternative assets if they document their assessment of six factors: performance, fees, liquidity, valuation, performance benchmark and complexity.
Morningstar's multi-asset and alternative strategies analysts say that checklist is easy for public securities and hard for private ones. In their words: "Private markets complicate all six, not only because of their own inherent complexity but also because of difficulties in evaluating performance, fees, liquidity, and valuations."
Alexander Davis, editor of Morningstar and PitchBook's Public Meets Private newsletter, wrote: "It's fair to wonder whether money managers are pushing too hard, and too fast, to pair everyday investors with hard-to-value, hard-to-trade alternative assets that are sometimes complex for even the most sophisticated people in the market."
The White House has framed the effort as a way to "democratize access to private assets." The pitch is that wealthy investors and pension funds have long had access to private markets and ordinary savers should too. GAO's own review leaves that argument open: some of the research it examined did show private equity beating public stocks.
The Labor Department has not said when the proposal will be finalized.
The debt and exit pressure
In a column published today, Nov. 21, in Fortune, George Mason University finance professor Derek Horstmeyer links the retail push to trouble inside the industry.
He cites PitchBook data showing 30% of private equity holdings have sat in portfolios for six years or more, a record. Funds typically aim to exit in three to five years.
Horstmeyer also points to roughly $300 billion in debt owed by private equity-backed companies that comes due in 2028 and 2029. Most of it was refinanced in 2020 and 2021, when rates were near zero, and will have to be refinanced at far higher rates.
His conclusion is his own argument, not an established fact: with traditional exits stalled, the industry is looking for new buyers, and retail investors are the obvious candidates. He says private holdings already appear in ETFs, mutual funds and perpetual products, and that private credit is gradually entering 401(k)s.
No filing or regulator cited here shows that any firm is moving assets into retirement accounts to ease its own debt maturities. That motive is Horstmeyer's inference.
Fees and getting your money out
The cost gap is documented. The traditional private equity structure charges 2% of assets and 20% of profits. The average large-cap equity ETF carries an expense ratio around 0.2%.
WisdomTree's private credit ETF, ticker HYIN, carries an annual expense ratio of 4.34%. A fund with that cost has to earn more than 4.34% a year before an investor sees a gain.
Valuation is the other problem. Unlisted assets have no daily market price. Horstmeyer notes that pricing them traditionally takes months of due diligence by specialists, not the minutes a retail investor might spend.
Liquidity has already been tested. Horstmeyer writes that this summer wealthy investors filed redemption requests with several business development companies and private credit funds, and some requests were rejected when volume exceeded the limits written into the fund agreements. Those limits are standard terms of semiliquid funds. A 401(k) saver in the same product would be bound by the same gates.
Cliff Asness, the AQR co-founder, has called the understatement of risk in private assets "volatility laundering," because infrequent appraisals make returns look smoother than they are.
Deregulation and disclosure
Renée M. Jones, a Boston College law professor who directed the SEC's Division of Corporate Finance from 2021 to 2023, argues in her book Untamed Unicorns, published in August, that deregulation has eroded safeguards written after the 1929 crash.
Billion-dollar private companies were once rare. Now they are common, and they operate without the public scrutiny that comes with listing, she says.
Jones also told Morningstar that a proposal to let public companies report twice a year instead of quarterly would be "disastrous." Her reasoning is that existing rules assume quarterly reporting and that less frequent disclosure would widen the information gap between insiders and the public.
Horstmeyer says changes to the definition of "sophisticated investors" and looser enforcement have opened the door to retail buyers.
What comes next
The Labor Department proposal is still pending, and GAO has now documented that the department has not explained to plan sponsors how private equity differs from conventional holdings. Whether DOL issues that guidance before or after it finalizes the rule is an open question.
Until it does, the six-factor documentation test will be applied by plan fiduciaries to an asset class that GAO found has no agreed performance benchmark.
Sources used for this briefing
7 links from 6 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)
These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.