READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

California Subpoenas Nvidia Over China Chip Exports as Huang Is Set to Testify Dec. 1

California Subpoenas Nvidia Over China Chip Exports as Huang Is Set to Testify Dec. 1
Two days after the House Foreign Affairs Committee released records showing Commerce approved 879,868 Nvidia and AMD chips for China, California Attorney General Rob Bonta subpoenaed Nvidia. Huang is due before several congressional committees on Dec. 1, and the committee's top Democrat wants Lutnick and Kessler testifying in public. Whether any of the approved chips actually shipped is still unanswered.

Since the House Foreign Affairs Committee released Commerce Department license records on Thursday, Nov. 19, showing 879,868 Nvidia and AMD chips approved for China between December and May, the fallout has spread from Washington to Sacramento.

California Attorney General Rob Bonta issued an investigative subpoena to Nvidia on Thursday. His office is examining whether exports of the company's advanced chips ended up in China in violation of U.S. restrictions. It is also looking at whether former CEO Jensen Huang's actions led to China obtaining confidential information.

"The conduct of Nvidia and its former chief executive raises bright red flags, including about the ways in which the company may have misled investors," Bonta said. He added that "companies cannot mislead their investors."

No charges have been filed. A subpoena is an information demand, not a finding.

Huang's testimony and the Megaspeed link

Huang resigned as CEO on Nov. 12 after admitting to an affair with a former executive at Megaspeed, the Singapore-based Nvidia customer. U.S. intelligence officials suspect she is an agent of Beijing's spy agencies.

Megaspeed has bought nearly $5 billion of Nvidia chips and hardware in recent years and is under investigation for possibly diverting restricted chips to China. The company says it is a "legitimate and lawful" business and that she left late last year.

Huang is due to testify before several congressional committees on Dec. 1 over the potential national security breach.

Nvidia chair Harvey Jones said this week the company has no plans to bring Huang back, even after Huang said he would be "honoured" to return. Elon Musk and other tech executives had campaigned for his reinstatement.

What the license files show

Commerce's Bureau of Industry and Security approved 21 applications covering 879,868 chips, out of 3.4 million requested. The approvals include 75,000 chips for Alibaba, 150,000 for Tencent, 43,000 for Baidu and 4,000 for BYD. All four are on the Pentagon's list of Chinese military companies.

The records list the chips as "approved but not shipped." Nobody has said publicly how many later left the country.

Every application rated the risk of diversion as "low," according to the committee. It said that was despite several of the IT firms assigned to install the chips having been accused of diverting them.

Chairman Brian Mast said at the committee meeting that two names in Nvidia's applications, Maginfra and New Matrix, are believed to be smuggling fronts. "Both are fake companies," he said. "If BIS approved the sale of these chips to these firms, obviously that is of tremendous concern to us."

One undecided application sought 40,800 chips for New Century Lettal Data Service, which The New York Times has linked to Megaspeed. Commerce said this week that Nvidia put Megaspeed on a "no sell" list last year. The application was filed in April of this year.

Demands for hearings

Rep. Gregory Meeks, the committee's ranking Democrat, said the panel approved the disclosure by unanimous consent. He called the record "a troubling contradiction." Even as BIS license reviews faced massive delays, he said, the agency "seemed to approve licenses for advanced chips to China with little scrutiny."

Meeks said oversight must include public hearings with Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and BIS Undersecretary Jeffrey Kessler. Commerce did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the release.

Chris McGuire, a former U.S. official and expert on U.S.-China technology policy, said that over 30% of the chips going to Chinese military-designated companies is "astonishing." He said it "calls into question whether Commerce conducted any serious national security review."

Nvidia's position is that the approvals were "subject to strict conditions." The company has also stopped shipping licensed Hopper data center chips to China. Interim CEO Colette Kress said so on Tuesday's earnings call without giving a reason. Nvidia booked $2.4 billion in licensed Hopper sales to China in its fiscal third quarter.

The Chinese companies dispute the military label. Alibaba, Tencent, Baidu and BYD have all challenged their inclusion on the list, and Alibaba and BYD are suing the U.S. government over it.

Markets

Nvidia shares are down about a fifth since Huang admitted the affair. The stock hit a one-year low at Thursday's close, and almost $1 trillion has come off its market value.

AMD closed down almost 8% on Thursday after reports tied to short seller Hunterbrook alleged links to China and "circular financing" of customers. Those are the publishers' allegations, and Hunterbrook is betting against the stock.

Lawmakers from both parties have called for legislation tightening AI chip export restrictions on China and other rivals.

The next fixed date is Dec. 1, when Huang is scheduled to face the committees. Still open is whether any of the 879,868 approved chips reached China, a question only Commerce and the companies can answer.

Sources used for this briefing

6 links from 6 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center
The TelegraphWhite House approves chip sales to Chinese military
center-left
QuartzU.S. approved Nvidia and AMD AI chip sales to China, records show
center-left
Al JazeeraUS signed off on sales of nearly 900,000 AI chips to China in six months
center-left
CBS NewsNvidia says it will stop selling some AI data center chips to China
Gov
foreignaffairs.houseChairman Brian Mast Exercises Legislative Authority to Publicly Release AI Chip License Information for China
left
The GuardianCalifornia investigates Nvidia over whether chip exports ended up in China

More coverage: Nvidia and China