READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Mbappé, Real Madrid and La Liga Apologize to China After 'Chinese Dictator' Remark About a Meme

Mbappé, Real Madrid and La Liga Apologize to China After 'Chinese Dictator' Remark About a Meme
Kylian Mbappé joked about a meme in a French talk show clip, and within days three Chinese sponsors had dropped him and Beijing was threatening La Liga's broadcast deal. Mbappé, Real Madrid and La Liga all apologized. The unresolved question is whether anyone, from governments to clubs, will answer this kind of pressure collectively.

After a joke about a meme, Kylian Mbappé lost sponsors, Beijing responded with a warning on state media, and his club and his league apologized to China. Beijing says only that the offended public will reject such remarks, and the sponsors have not said why they left.

The sequence began in late October. A meme superimposing the Real Madrid striker onto the body of Mao Zedong went largely unnoticed until a Chinese football forum picked it up.

What Mbappé actually said

In a clip from the French talk show The Bridge, Mbappé was asked about memes of himself. He said the funniest showed "some guy—I think he's a Chinese dictator."

He did not name Mao. The Diplomat notes that Mbappé, himself nicknamed "the dictator," has often been edited onto historical dictators in social media memes, and that he appeared oblivious to who the figure was.

That context did not slow Beijing down.

Beijing's response

Within a day, three Chinese sponsors had dropped him. According to a Fortune commentary, his name and likeness were also pulled from social media posts and from ads and stores in China for Dior, Hublot, On and Adidas, and his accounts on Xiaohongshu and Weibo were restricted.

Chinese state television threatened to suspend La Liga broadcasts. One account says matches were already taken off the air. The Global Times and China Daily, meanwhile, went after Real Madrid, which is sponsored by Chinese electronics maker Hisense.

A spokesperson for China's Ministry of Foreign Affairs described the backlash as natural. "Any rhetoric or action that hurts the feelings of the Chinese people will naturally be rejected across the sectors in China," the spokesperson said.

That is the position of the Chinese government: remarks that offend the Chinese public bring consequences from across Chinese society and business. Beijing has not claimed it ordered the sponsors' exits, and the sponsors have not said why they left.

Three apologies

Mbappé apologized first. "I have deep respect for the Chinese people and their history, and I am sincerely sorry," he said, calling his comment "ill-judged."

La Liga followed, with president Javier Tebas apologizing to Chinese fans. The league earns an estimated $100 million a year from Chinese media rights.

Real Madrid then apologized to the Chinese people for any "discomfort" Mbappé's words had caused. The club has millions of Chinese fans and reportedly sells about 15% of its jerseys there.

The money explains the speed. A $100 million annual rights stream and a sizable share of a club's merchandise sales are not things a league or a club walks away from over a talk-show quip.

Not the first time

The pattern spans the past decade. In October 2019, a single tweet about the Hong Kong protests by Houston Rockets general manager Daryl Morey led all 11 of the NBA's official Chinese partners to suspend ties. State media canceled broadcasts, and the league lost hundreds of millions of dollars, according to the Fortune commentary.

Hollywood has adjusted too. MGM digitally turned the Chinese invaders in its "Red Dawn" remake into North Koreans. Taiwanese and Japanese flags vanished from Tom Cruise's jacket in the first trailer for "Top Gun: Maverick." John Cena has also apologized to China.

The Diplomat calls the playbook "emotional assertiveness": Chinese officials publicly voice indignation on behalf of the Chinese population to push an offender into acknowledging Beijing's red lines, and to deter everyone else from crossing them. What set the Mbappé case apart, the publication argues, was the apolitical setting and the disproportionate reaction.

The proposed fix

The Fortune commentary argues the apologies were the only rational move for Mbappé, Real Madrid and La Liga, because none of them can take on a nation-state alone. "As long as governments won't stand up to China, no company or individual will—and certainly no athlete, no matter how famous," it says.

Its answer is not braver individuals but a "collective economic deterrence pledge," under which coercion against one country's companies or people would be answered by all.

Writers in National Review take a similar view of the power involved, describing the Chinese Communist Party's combination of "state power, corporate money, and nationalist outrage."

No government has been named as committing to such a pledge. Meanwhile, a French footballer, a Spanish club and Spain's top league have each said sorry to Beijing for a joke about a meme.

The Diplomat leaves the open question: whether all Western celebrities, companies and perhaps even media will now have to toe Beijing's red lines, or whether the next target will find anyone willing to stand beside them.

Sources used for this briefing

5 links from 5 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center-left
FortuneMbappé’s apology is a warning: China’s economic coercion needs a collective response
center-left
The DiplomatMbappe’s Mao Mess: The Expansion of China’s Emotional Assertiveness
right
National ReviewMbappé Meets His Match
unknown
CrayonMbappé’s apology is a warning: China’s economic coercion needs a collective response
unknown
Symplexia NewsMbappé’s apology is a warning: China’s economic coercion needs a collective response | Fortune - Symplexia Labs