Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.
Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.
Insurance Commissioner-Elect Jane Kim Proposes State-Run Wildfire Pool Covering Up to $400,000 Per Home

Since Jane Kim declared victory in the Nov. 3 insurance commissioner race, the former San Francisco supervisor has begun laying out how she would replace much of California's private wildfire insurance market with a state-run pool.
Kim led fellow Democrat Ben Allen 53% to 47% with about 65% of ballots counted when she claimed the win. Allen, who is termed out of the Legislature, called to congratulate her. She takes office Jan. 4, succeeding Ricardo Lara, who has held the job since January 2019.
What Kim is proposing
Her "Natural Disaster Insurance for All" plan would have homeowners pay into a public, nonprofit pool covering up to $400,000 in rebuilding costs after a wildfire. Kim has said the focus is modest homes, not mansions.
Private insurers would keep a role. They could offer coverage above that limit and would continue to cover theft, water damage and ordinary house fires.
Premiums would have two parts, according to Kim's campaign website. One would reflect the home's own wildfire risk based on location, structure and surroundings. The other would build a reserve for years of widespread disaster that no single homeowner or neighborhood could absorb.
The program would cover only existing homes, a design meant to discourage building in wildfire zones.
Kim told The Center Square the program would not cost taxpayers any money. She said Californians spend about $18 billion a year insuring their homes, with $3 billion to $6 billion of that going to wildfire coverage, and that money could flow to the state instead of private companies.
Surplus money, she said, would be invested and then she would "drive it back into our communities" for fire-proofing, flood-proofing and public infrastructure. "One is that it's nonprofit and so it doesn't extort homeowners, and excess profits don't go to CEO pay and shareholders and Super Bowl ads," she said in an interview.
The market she inherits
The numbers behind the pitch are large. The Jan. 7, 2025, fires damaged or destroyed more than 16,000 structures in the Pacific Palisades and Altadena areas alone. Insured losses from the Los Angeles fires were estimated at $40 billion.
The California FAIR Plan, the insurer of last resort, now holds about 677,000 residential policies, more than double its 2022 count. It covers $773 billion of property, caps reimbursement at $3 million per residence, and was granted a 29% premium increase this year.
The Department of Insurance reports that homeowners and fire coverage bills topped $19 billion in 2025, while insurers incurred more than $31 billion in losses on those policies.
Lara's department has pending actions against State Farm, the state's largest individual insurer, and the FAIR Plan over their handling of claims from the January 2025 fires. Lara's rate-modeling rules have been embraced by the industry, and a commentary published Nov. 13 says Allstate, State Farm and other carriers are taking steps to expand homeowner coverage. Kim has criticized the price increases that followed.
A recent poll by the Insurance Fairness Project and Data for Progress found almost half of Californians say they pay more for home or renters insurance than last year.
The objections
The idea is not entirely new. A similar option was briefly outlined in a natural catastrophe resilience study ordered by Gov. Gavin Newsom this year. The state also already runs the California Earthquake Authority, created in 1996 after the Northridge quake because insurers would not offer the coverage.
But no U.S. state has run a wildfire program like this one. Industry officials and consumer advocates say startup financing and claims handling remain undefined, and Kim concedes it is a starting point.
"What she's proposing is what would be a really big wholesale change here in California, and there are a lot of details, a lot of steps, between now and that coming together," said Denni Ritter, a government relations vice president at the American Property Casualty Insurance Association.
Republican Minority Leader Roger Niello of Fair Oaks told The Center Square he is worried about what happens to taxpayers if the state takes on the risk. "In the interest of taxpayers, I think to take on that kind of risk makes no sense," he said. Niello said he does not have a preferred solution of his own.
The stakes in that dispute are specific. A pool capped at $400,000 per home would be exposed to a bad fire season, and Kim says surplus money would be spent on mitigation rather than held for losses. She has not yet said what backstops the pool if claims outrun reserves. Her campaign materials describe a reserve for catastrophic years, but the size and funding of it are not spelled out.
Politics and what is still missing
Kim, endorsed by Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Ro Khanna, ran as what she called an "unabashed and unapologetic populist progressive." Her most recent job was director of the California Working Families Party. She will be the ninth person, and the first woman and first Asian American, to hold the office since it became elected in 1988.
The commissioner regulates rates and can adopt rules, but a government-run insurer would require legislation. Kim has said she will need to write the plan with Democratic Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra and the new Legislature.
She has also not addressed a separate risk: rising seas. El Niño conditions are expected to bring heavy rain and unusually high tides this winter, and coastal damage has already hit Malibu, Long Beach, Huntington Beach, Laguna Beach and San Clemente this year.
The next concrete test comes after Jan. 4, when Kim takes over the Department of Insurance and has to turn a campaign outline into a bill and a financing plan that the Legislature and Becerra will accept.
Sources used for this briefing
7 links from 7 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)
These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.