READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Federal Judge Vacates DHS Rule Capping International Student Stays at Four Years

Federal Judge Vacates DHS Rule Capping International Student Stays at Four Years
Massachusetts District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV, a George W. Bush appointee, vacated the Department of Homeland Security's rule ending open-ended "duration of status" for student and exchange visas. He found DHS exceeded its authority and failed to justify the change. The rule never took effect, and the administration's next option is an appeal to the 1st Circuit.

Since DHS published the rule in July, it has been blocked from taking effect, and on Monday, Nov. 16, a federal judge in Boston struck it down for good.

District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV vacated the Department of Homeland Security rule under the Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C. § 706. He granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs and denied the government's request to uphold the policy. Saylor was appointed by President George W. Bush.

What the rule would have done

For decades, international students on F visas, researchers and professors on J visas, and foreign journalists on I visas have been admitted under "duration of status." They can stay as long as they remain enrolled or employed and comply with the terms of their status.

The DHS rule would have replaced that with a fixed admission period, generally capped at four years for F and J holders. Anyone who needed more time, including PhD students and others in longer programs, would have had to apply to the government for an extension.

The rule also would have restricted school transfers, changes of academic program and additional degrees, and added immigration reviews.

It was scheduled to take effect in September. A coalition of higher education and labor groups sued in August, and Saylor temporarily blocked the rule in September while the case proceeded. Plaintiffs included the Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, and the United Auto Workers.

The judge's findings

Saylor found the rule "arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and otherwise not in accordance with law." He ruled DHS failed to properly weigh costs and benefits. He also said the department never showed how discretionary renewals after four years would improve fraud detection or outweigh "the immense costs of abandoning the existing system."

He also faulted DHS for not adequately considering less burdensome tools, including the existing Student and Exchange Visitor Information System, or SEVIS. SEVIS tracks enrollment, status and compliance using reports from schools.

On the statute, Saylor concluded that DHS's stated goals of national security and fraud prevention were "not reasonably related to the nature and purpose of the F-1 visa program."

His sharpest passage: "Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity — providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States — that Congress sought to permit and encourage. The statute simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority to undermine the F-1 visa program."

He also wrote that DHS acknowledges there are legitimate reasons for a student to pursue another degree at the same or a lower level, such as an M.B.A. after a J.D. The rule, he said, would effectively bar that student from entering the country.

The administration's argument

DHS said extensions would give officials more chances to catch fraud, security risks and immigration violations, citing past abuse of the student visa system. Its lawyers argued that open-ended admission periods prevent regular checks on whether foreign nationals are following their visa conditions.

The department has also said SEVIS is "not designed for performing all relevant fraud and security screening." Administration officials say tighter student visa policies fight fraud and keep Americans from competing with international students for work.

Adam Klein, a former senior DHS official and co-founder of Globali.ai, told Newsweek that DHS "has a legitimate interest in identifying students who violate their status or use educational programs improperly." He said the ruling is "particularly important for doctoral students, researchers, and others whose academic programs do not necessarily fit within a fixed timetable."

The plaintiffs argued the rule was arbitrary and would deter students from coming. Miriam Feldblum, president and CEO of the Presidents' Alliance, called the decision a "clear and important victory" for international students, scholars and host universities. She said the rule would have worsened falling enrollment and burdened campuses.

The Institute of International Education puts the drop in new international enrollment at 15% this fall.

What the ruling does and does not settle

Saylor noted the current system has been in place for decades and the new rule never took effect. Nothing changes for students on the ground, and the existing definition of duration of status stays.

The ruling turns on authority and the quality of DHS's rulemaking record, not on whether fraud in the student visa system is real. A tighter regime would need either a better-documented rule that fits the F-1 statute, or a law from Congress.

The administration can appeal to the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Sources used for this briefing

8 links from 8 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center-left
Yahoo NewsJudge strikes down Trump’s new visa limit on foreign students
center-left
NBC NewsJudge to order release of some records in federal search of Ilhan Omar’s home
left
Raw StoryTrump admin’s attack on foreign students shredded by conservative judge: report
right
Fox NewsBush-appointed judge torpedoes Trump immigration rule, rips DHS for overstepping its authority
right
NY PostIlhan Omar probe secrets set to be revealed after search warrant ordered released
unknown
InquisitrFederal judge overturns Trump's 4-year student visa limit
unknown
Mezha.netBush-appointed judge strikes down Trump administration visa rule, says DHS exceeded its authority | Межа
unknown
NewsBytesJudge strikes down Trump administration's rule limiting foreign students' stays