READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Zelenskyy Says He Doesn't Know What a U.S. 'Article 5-Like' Guarantee Means, Asks Where American Troops Fit

Zelenskyy Says He Doesn't Know What a U.S. 'Article 5-Like' Guarantee Means, Asks Where American Troops Fit
After the Coalition of the Willing met in Berlin on Nov. 19, Zelenskyy said he is not sure Kyiv and Washington share the same understanding of an Article 5-style guarantee. U.S. envoy Jared Kushner called such a pledge a "really, really big deal" that must serve American interests. Whether it includes a single American soldier is still unanswered.

The idea of an Article 5-like security guarantee for Ukraine was first floated in December 2025 and then went nowhere as peace talks stalled. On Thursday, Nov. 19, it came back at a Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin, and Volodymyr Zelenskyy used the moment to ask what Washington actually means by it.

"I'm not sure we have a common acceptance of Article 5," Zelenskyy told reporters after the meeting. "What does it mean?"

Kushner: Trump is "open," with conditions

U.S. special envoy Jared Kushner attended the Berlin meeting. Speaking alongside Zelenskyy, he said President Donald Trump is "open" to giving a post-war Ukraine such a commitment.

"From an American perspective, giving an Article 5-like security guarantee is a really, really big deal," Kushner said. "Obviously, it has to be in America's interest to do that. And we also have to make sure that it's part of a broader security package."

Kushner also claimed Russia has become "comfortable" with the concept. He conceded that "there's a lot of scepticism and disbelief" about it in Moscow. He said Russia's intention is "to not have another war in the future" and argued for restarting dialogue between Europe and Russia.

The Kremlin's own position was not part of the Berlin remarks. The claim that Moscow accepts the idea comes from Kushner alone.

Zelenskyy's question: what about American soldiers?

Zelenskyy said he understands the U.S. envoys, Kushner and Steve Witkoff, discussed the concept with Trump, with the Russian side and with the Europeans. He said they appear ready to move toward real negotiations and a security process built on the Article 5 model.

But he said the substance is unclear. In his reading, Article 5 means partner forces are present on a country's soil.

"My question is, what about American soldiers?" he said. "Do you have an answer on it? Me not. For today. I don't know the answer."

He said Ukraine would welcome U.S. bases, as in the Middle East, noting that the countries hosting them are not NATO members either. He added that he is neither supportive nor unsupportive of any particular model yet.

There is a wrinkle in the terminology. NATO's Article 5 treaty text says an armed attack on one ally is an attack on all. It leaves each member free to decide what action it considers necessary, including armed force. It does not by itself station troops anywhere. That gap between the label and the content is what Zelenskyy is pressing on.

What Washington has already signaled

This is not the first time he has raised it. At a Nov. 13 media briefing, Zelenskyy said the U.S. government had offered Ukraine guarantees "similar to Articles 4 and 5" of the NATO Treaty. When he asked whether U.S. troops would be stationed on Ukrainian soil under such an arrangement, he said Washington responded negatively.

According to Zelenskyy, U.S. officials describe the guarantees as bilateral. He compared them to those given to Israel or to Arab states that host U.S. bases and air defenses. Ukraine, he said, needs clear provisions spelling out what that means.

The "when, not if" problem

Zelenskyy also wants the response to a renewed attack settled in advance.

"What will partners do if, sorry to be sceptical, not if, but when, (Russians) will try to do it again?" he said. The answer, he argued, has to be clear "not only to the partners," but to Ukrainians, to societies and to the investors and businesses he expects to come to Ukraine.

That last point is practical. Reconstruction money depends on investors believing the peace will hold.

The skeptics

Not everyone thinks the guarantee is worth chasing. Writing for the Royal United Services Institute, Eric Ciaramella, a former Biden administration Russia and Ukraine analyst, argues Ukraine should give up its aspirations to an "Article 5-style" guarantee in negotiations.

National Review's Michael Brendan Dougherty, citing Ciaramella, called NATO-style guarantees for Ukraine never credible. He argued that if the U.S. and European nations cannot or will not directly defend Ukraine, it is fair to ask why the Biden administration kept the "Open Door" policy alive before 2022. Dougherty said that question is now the top item on Russia's negotiating agenda.

Kushner's own conditions point the same direction. A guarantee that must be "in America's interest" and bundled into a "broader security package" is not an automatic defense commitment.

Zelenskyy's read on the broader talks

Zelenskyy said the chances of ending the war next year are high "if the US genuinely pressures Russia." He argued that if the U.S. and China want to stop Russia, they should stop trading with it. He called the coming winter difficult.

He also pointed to the U.S. Congress after the recent elections. "After winter, there will be more than just spring," he said. "There will also be Congress."

Photographed at the Berlin summit with Zelenskyy were UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz.

Kyiv says it expects a multilateral meeting to be organized as soon as possible, with partner support, to continue work on the guarantees. No date for that meeting has been announced. Nor has Washington said whether the guarantee it is discussing would put U.S. forces on Ukrainian territory, the question Zelenskyy put to it in Berlin.

Sources used for this briefing

7 links from 7 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center
Euronews'What does it mean?' Zelenskyy asks US to clarify Article 5-like guarantee
right
BreitbartUkrainian President Zelenskyy presses Western allies for clear postwar security guarantees
right
National ReviewNATO Security Guarantees for Ukraine Were Never Credible
unknown
Censor.netZelenskyy: I am not sure Ukraine and its partners share same understanding of security guarantees modeled on NATO’s Article 5
unknown
Ukrainska PravdaZelenskyy: I am not sure Ukraine and US have same understanding of Article 5
unknown
Ukrainska Pravda English (english.nv.ua)Zelenskyy: Ukraine and allies may interpret security guarantees differently
unknown
ShelterZelenskyy stated that the U.S. must explain what security guarantees modeled after NATO's Article 5 would entail