READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Texas executes Reinaldo Dennes in procedure lasting over an hour; adviser says he screamed, state says protocols were followed

Texas executes Reinaldo Dennes in procedure lasting over an hour; adviser says he screamed, state says protocols were followed
Reinaldo Dennes, 70, was executed by lethal injection in Huntsville on Thursday, Nov. 19, after staff struggled to find a vein. His spiritual adviser describes minutes of screaming, while Texas says the execution was a success and that the pain complaints don't match its timeline. The dispute lands weeks after Tennessee's failed attempt on Christa Pike, and it is fueling calls for a national pause on lethal injection.

Reinaldo Dennes, 70, was put to death at the Huntsville penitentiary on Thursday night in an execution that took 63 minutes for him to be proclaimed dead. Prison staff struggled to find a vein for the two IV lines that carried the sedative pentobarbital.

Texas says it went according to plan. The man standing next to the gurney says it did not.

What happened in the chamber

Dennes was convicted of capital murder for the January 1996 shooting of Janos Szucs, a diamond dealer, during a robbery in Houston.

The Texas Department of Criminal Justice (TDCJ) gave a timeline. The lethal dose began at 6:52 p.m. and Dennes was pronounced dead at 7:08 p.m. That is 16 minutes between the start of the lethal dose and the pronouncement. The overall procedure ran more than an hour, and the agency's timeline covers only the span from the dose to the pronouncement.

TDCJ spokeswoman Amanda Hernandez said IVs went into "the most viable veins available, in the left foot and left side of the neck."

The spiritual adviser's account

The Rev. Jeff Hood stood beside the gurney with his hand on Dennes's shoulder. He says Dennes screamed that his leg was "on fire" and fought the restraints for up to five minutes. According to Hood, Dennes begged: "Please kill me, kill me."

Hood says he has served as a spiritual adviser to more than a dozen death row inmates. He says he has never before experienced a condemned inmate being able to speak roughly 30 seconds after receiving a lethal injection.

"These drugs are supposed to render you unconscious very quickly," Hood told reporters at a press conference Friday. "There was no sequence last night."

Hood is a longtime opponent of the death penalty. That is his stated position, and his is the detailed eyewitness account that has been made public.

Texas disputes the pain claims

Hernandez rejected the word "botched." "The agency followed all of its protocols and the execution was successfully carried out," she said.

She also said Dennes made allegations of pain in locations where there were no IVs established and prior to any drugs being administered. Asked whether that meant he was faking, she answered, "I think, yeah, there were allegations," and added, "There was nothing abnormal on our part."

She said the agency has had to insert IVs in other locations before, and that other inmates have also made allegations of pain immediately.

Hood rejected that account. His argument is that if the drug works as designed, a man should be unconscious within 30 seconds, not still screaming three or four minutes in.

Jonathan Groner, an emeritus professor of clinical surgery at Ohio State University and an expert on execution methods, said the sites where lines were placed pointed to difficulties. In his view, lethal injections carried out without proper medical equipment and skills can cause suffering.

A pattern after Tennessee

Dennes's execution follows the failed attempt on Christa Pike in Tennessee on Sept. 30. She became the first known person in U.S. history to endure a complete lethal injection protocol and survive. The Washington Post reported that she woke from a coma with burned, blistered arms and difficulty speaking.

Tennessee also failed to execute Tony Carruthers on May 21 when staff could not establish the second IV line its protocol requires.

Data from the Death Penalty Information Center shows 16 botched lethal injection executions across eight states in the past decade. Robin Maher, the center's executive director, asked: "How many more of these botched executions will be tolerated by the American people?"

Maya Foa, chief executive of the human rights group Reprieve, called for a moratorium. "Lethal injection is torture," she said, "and Reinaldo Dennes was not sentenced to be tortured."

The legal bar and the alternatives

The Supreme Court has affirmed there is no right to a painless death. Under that precedent, an inmate challenging a method must show a substantial risk of severe pain and propose a feasible alternative that would significantly reduce it.

That standard gives states a reason to pick methods they can defend as least painful. In April the Justice Department released a report directing the Federal Bureau of Prisons to expand the available methods. It listed firing squads first, ahead of nitrogen gas and electrocution. The department asserts that firing squads are less painful and have historically had the fewest botched executions.

Of the states that authorize firing squads, Idaho is the only one that retains it as a primary option, as of July.

The political backdrop

The Guardian reported that the way Texas conducts executions is likely to come under fresh review given the political upheaval in the state's midterm elections. Democrat Gina Hinojosa won the governor's mansion, and Democrats flipped 20 state House seats and took all seats up for election on the Texas supreme court and court of criminal appeals.

What is still unclear is what Dennes experienced between the first needle and the pronouncement. Texas points to its timeline and protocol. Hood points to what he saw and heard.

Sources used for this briefing

6 links from 6 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center-right
NewsweekDeath row pastor describes horror of "botched" Texas execution: "Torture"
left
The GuardianLatest botched execution prompts calls for US moratorium on lethal injections
left
Washington PostA failed execution, a shrinking death row and a historic moment for capital punishment
unknown
finwire.ioLatest botched execution prompts calls for US moratorium on lethal injections
unknown
blogs.law.ox.ac.ukA revival of firing squads is not the solution to America’s
unknown
ua.newsTexas calls for moratorium on lethal injections — The Guardian