READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Rubio Says 'Zero Evidence' Links U.S. Outages or Points to Hackers, as Apple and NSA Offer Causes

Rubio Says 'Zero Evidence' Links U.S. Outages or Points to Hackers, as Apple and NSA Offer Causes
Secretary of State Marco Rubio said in Manila on Wednesday that the administration has "zero evidence" the week's outages at Microsoft, the FAA, banks, Apple and the NSA are connected or the work of any hostile actor. Apple and the NSA have now given on-record explanations, internal update and scheduled maintenance, but the root cause of the FAA's nationwide ground stop is still an open question.

Since Microsoft's worldwide outage on Thursday, Nov. 12, a string of failures has hit air travel, banks, Apple and the NSA, and on Wednesday, Nov. 18, local time in Manila, Secretary of State Marco Rubio became the latest senior official to say none of it points to an attack.

"We have zero evidence or any reason to believe that any of these isolated or individual instances have anything to do with nefarious actors, with cyber hackers, with criminals, with another nation state, with a malign actor of any kind," Rubio told reporters. He is traveling with President Trump and is due in Shenzhen, China, for the APEC summit.

He went further than the attack question. "The Microsoft incident has nothing to do with what we saw with the FAA. The FAA has nothing to do with what we saw with the banks," Rubio said. "Each of them are distinct, and they're different in their causation."

Apple and the NSA name causes

Two gaps from earlier in the week have now been filled by the organizations themselves.

Apple said the iCloud and Apple Pay problems on Tuesday, Nov. 17, were triggered by an internal update and were not a cyberattack.

The NSA acknowledged that its internal network for classified communications went down Tuesday. The agency described it as "temporary degradation during scheduled routine maintenance" and said its capabilities remained operational and "our ability to defend national security continues."

What each organization has said

Microsoft traced its outage, which hit Outlook and Teams, to "an earlier network capacity upgrade." It said the cause was technical, not malicious.

The FAA blamed a router upgrade for Friday's ground stop, the longest since the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. The U.S. transport secretary said the problem came from a copper wire upgrade and outdated equipment. Federal officials have also identified a contractor performing maintenance updates. Those accounts differ in detail, and CBS News reports key questions remain about the underlying cause of the systemwide failure.

On Monday, Chase said "a software bug" caused the problems that rippled to other banks and Zelle, and called it "not cyber-related." United Airlines said a software issue delayed about 150 departing flights the same day.

Officials line up behind the no-attack position

Rubio's remarks followed similar ones from other officials. Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton said on Fox Business Network, "Looking very diligently across the landscape, we are not seeing this as a cyber-attack incident." He said "lots of institutions" are patching or upgrading systems, which has caused disruption.

Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin told CNBC: "I can tell you with complete certainty that we are not under attack. There's no cyber threat that's taking place."

Sen. Mark Warner, the Virginia Democrat who is vice chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee, also said there is no indication of an attack. He pointed to a different pressure point. "AI is making it possible to identify vulnerabilities across enormous numbers of systems at unprecedented speed," Warner wrote on X, "putting tremendous strain on systems that weren't built to handle that pace of change."

Rubio made a similar structural argument. "The more technology becomes embedded into our everyday lives, the more the vulnerabilities become real," he said, adding that criminals can now rob banks "from behind a computer screen halfway around the world."

The transparency complaint

Not everyone is satisfied with the messaging. Karoline Leavitt, Trump's former press secretary, said on Fox News that "transparency is key" and that the White House needs to do more to explain the situation. She later praised the White House for putting Clayton on air.

The Associated Press reported that even some staunch Trump allies have accused the administration of lying to Americans or hiding information about the true cause. It did not name them in the material we reviewed, and no evidence of concealment has been presented.

Trump himself was dismissive when asked Tuesday about the outages. "It's life. When you're big and powerful and you have all the money, things like that happen. It's fine," he said in Manila.

Rubio was asked whether public fear could spur stockpiling or a run on the banks. He said the answer is for the government to share everything it knows. "Every indicator we have is that every single one of these events has an explanation or a cause that has nothing to do with a cyber-criminal," he said.

What remains open

The BBC reports that cybersecurity experts agree there is no evidence linking the outages and that many of the problems appear tied to updates of old infrastructure.

Still, "upgrade" and "maintenance" appear in nearly every explanation, from Microsoft to the FAA to the NSA. Rubio says the incidents are unrelated, and the organizations affected have each said theirs was not cyber-related. Whether the FAA will publish a single, consistent account of what failed on Friday, and what the contractor's role was, is the next test of the administration's promise to share what it knows.

Sources used for this briefing

8 links from 8 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center
BBCRubio says tech outages are not part of 'systemic attack' against US
center
Agence France-PresseRubio says no evidence recent tech outages are linked or 'nefarious'
center
ABS-CBN NewsRubio says no evidence recent tech outages are linked or 'nefarious' | ABS-CBN News
center-left
CBS NewsRubio says there's "zero evidence" recent tech outages are related
center-left
Al JazeeraRubio rules out cyberattacks or links between tech outages
left
The Guardian‘Zero’ evidence that recent cascade of tech outages are linked, says Rubio
unknown
WDBORubio says there's 'zero' information that US outages are linked or caused by a malign actor
unknown
The StandardRubio says no evidence recent tech outages are linked or 'nefarious'