READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Germany and UK Reject Pentagon Criticism of Ukraine's Deep Strikes Ahead of Thursday's Trump-Xi-Putin Meeting

Germany and UK Reject Pentagon Criticism of Ukraine's Deep Strikes Ahead of Thursday's Trump-Xi-Putin Meeting
Pentagon policy chief Elbridge Colby told Ukraine's backers in Brussels that deep strikes inside Russia have not helped end the war. Germany's Boris Pistorius called that criticism "quite a stupid thing," and Britain's Wes Streeting said it is "not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight." The split lands one day before Trump, Xi and Putin are due to meet in Shenzhen, where the Kremlin says Ukraine will come up at most informally.

With the Thursday, Nov. 19 trilateral in Shenzhen still on the calendar, Germany and the United Kingdom have publicly rejected a U.S. assessment that Ukraine's deep-strike campaign inside Russia is not working.

The dispute played out Tuesday, Nov. 17, at a meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group at NATO headquarters in Brussels.

Colby's case

U.S. Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Elbridge Colby told the room that "the public conversation focuses on the spectacle of deep strikes designed to incur pain on the Russian population." His assessment: "such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia's advances on the front line."

Colby did not dismiss Ukraine's whole strike effort. He called Kyiv's mid-range campaign, built on new drone technology and tactics to deny Russian advances at the front, "very effective." He also said Ukrainian forces gained more territory than Russia for the second straight month in October.

His objection was to strikes on civilian and commercial targets. He cited warehouses of Wildberries, Russia's biggest online retailer, and said such attacks "have actually probably hardened the Russian public's resolve and the Kremlin's own willingness to escalate." He argued military aid should prioritize Ukraine's ability to defend its front lines and hit Russian logistics and slow-moving forces at medium range.

Kyiv says the warehouses it hit supplied Russian forces with drone components, navigation equipment and other military parts. Wildberries and the Kremlin deny the company is involved in the war.

Berlin and London push back

Asked at a news conference whether he shared Colby's view, German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius did not soften his answer. Criticizing strikes meant to destroy strategic military and military-use targets in Russia, he said, "is quite a stupid thing, I think."

"Instead of criticizing that, we should rather criticize and talk about the terroristic strikes every night and every day on civil energy, water and heating infrastructure in Ukraine," Pistorius said. "This is kind of terrorism."

British Defence Secretary Wes Streeting said it is "not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war." He added: "There is no doubt in my mind that it has helped to degrade Putin's war machine, buying time and saving lives."

NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte also said it is important for Ukraine to defend itself, including by attacking logistical hubs.

Kyiv promises more

Ukrainian Defense Minister Yevhenii Khmara was in Brussels too, and he gave no ground. "I want the Russian Federation to receive a clear signal: for every strike they launch against our territory, we will respond twice or three times as forcefully. And we have the right to defend ourselves," he said.

Khmara said Russia began systematic attacks on Ukrainian bridges over the Dnipro on Oct. 1, and that the strike on the Crimea Bridge was planned after thorough reconnaissance. He said Ukraine's long-range strike capability will be tripled next year.

The U.S. position is not new. President Trump has previously urged Ukraine to stop hitting Russian oil refineries and diesel infrastructure, saying the attacks caused a global fuel shortage. Colby's Brussels remarks put a Pentagon argument about effectiveness and escalation in front of allies who fund and arm the campaign.

What Shenzhen will and will not cover

Trump arrived in Shenzhen on Wednesday from the Philippines, where he announced a new trade deal with President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. on Truth Social. Xi greeted him personally. Putin, who arrived the night before, was met by Politburo Standing Committee member Cai Qi.

Xi and Putin held their own talks Wednesday, Nov. 18. Putin told the APEC gathering he favors dialogue rather than ultimatums and expects Thursday's session to be "highly useful." At the family photo, Putin approached Trump and the two shook hands while Xi looked on.

Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said a full bilateral meeting between Putin and Trump is unlikely during the summit, though informal talks are possible. He said the two would exchange views on Ukraine and Iran if they get a chance to speak one-on-one. Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov said there could be more than one such opportunity.

The agenda for the three-way session, according to the sources, is expected to center on trade, artificial intelligence and nuclear weapons, with Ukraine as a topic observers are watching.

Whether Washington's skepticism about deep strikes shapes anything Trump says to Putin on Thursday is unanswered. Berlin and London have now said on the record that they will not press Kyiv to scale them back, and Khmara says the campaign will grow.

Sources used for this briefing

8 links from 6 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center
EuronewsXi and Putin meet ahead of planned summit with Trump
center-left
CNBCUkraine allies reject U.S. criticism of deep strikes inside Russia ahead of Trump-Putin-Xi summit
center-left
Kyiv PostGermany and Britain Push Back Against Pentagon Criticism of Ukraine
center-right
Times of IndiaWatch: Putin, Xi & Trump meet ahead of APEC family photo, trilateral
right
ZeroHedgeDawn Of A Multipolar World? Trump, Xi & Putin Meet At APEC Summit Ahead Of Historic Talks
unknown
EA WorldviewUkraine War, Day 1,728: "Quite A Stupid Thing" - European Allies on US Criticism of Kyiv's Strikes Inside Russia
unknown
Europe SaysTrump-Putin: Ukraine allies reject U.S. criticism of deep strikes - Ukraine
unknown
newscord.orgPistorius Rejects U.S. Criticism of Ukraine’s Deep Strikes Into Russia as “Stupid”: 10 outlets compared

More coverage: Donald Trump and Ukraine