READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Fifth Circuit Rules 2-1 That Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales, Sends Louisiana Dealing Case Back

Fifth Circuit Rules 2-1 That Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales, Sends Louisiana Dealing Case Back
A Fifth Circuit panel held Nov. 19 in United States v. Deare that the Second Amendment's plain text covers the sale of firearms, after the government conceded the point at oral argument. The ruling does not strike down federal dealer licensing. The district court must now decide whether the licensing requirement fits the nation's historical tradition of gun regulation.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled Thursday, Nov. 19, that the Second Amendment's plain text covers the sale of firearms. The 2-1 decision came in United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241.

The panel vacated a district court order that had denied Jeremiah Micah Deare's motion to dismiss his indictment. It sent the case back to the Western District of Louisiana for further proceedings.

What the court said

The unsigned opinion is two pages. Its core holding is one sentence: "The plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms."

The court leaned on its own 2025 decision in Reese v. ATF, which said "the right to 'keep and bear arms' surely implies the right to purchase them."

The government did not fight the point. During oral argument it conceded that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms.

The panel was Judge Catharina Haynes, a George W. Bush appointee, and Judges James Ho and Andrew Oldham, both appointed by Donald Trump. Haynes dissented.

The underlying case

Deare was indicted in the Western District of Louisiana (No. 6:21-CR-212-1) for conspiracy to engage in the business of dealing firearms without a federal firearms license, a violation of 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(1). He was also charged with making false statements about the records of licensed dealers.

He moved to dismiss, arguing the licensing requirement and related record-keeping rules violate the Second Amendment. The district court denied the motion in 2023.

It held that licensing and record-keeping rules do not implicate the Second Amendment because they do not affect an individual's right to keep or bear arms. It added that even if they did, they fit the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.

Deare went to trial. A jury convicted him on all counts, and he was sentenced to 97 months in federal prison.

What the ruling does not do

The decision does not invalidate federal dealer licensing. The panel decided only the first question: whether the Second Amendment's text reaches commercial sales. It did not reach the second step of the Bruen framework, which asks whether the licensing scheme is consistent with historical tradition.

A footnote lists Deare's other arguments. He says the statute is unconstitutionally vague, that the sentence is substantively unreasonable, and that the evidence was insufficient. The panel left those for the district court.

Whether the false-statements charge survives is less clear from the two-page opinion. Reason's analysis of the ruling reads it as not affecting that count.

The concurrence and the dissent

Judge Ho wrote separately to say he found the result gratifying. "It seems obvious that constitutional rights are meaningless if the Government can simply prohibit the means by which citizens are able to exercise those rights," he wrote.

Ho also took on the opposing view directly. The district court had called § 922(a)(1) "a modest regulation of the commercial activity of selling/transferring firearms to others," one that affects "only the seller."

Haynes took that position in her dissent. As Ho quoted her, "the Second Amendment … doesn't mention sellers," so "I do not think that the sellers of guns are covered."

The dispute is a real one. Haynes and the district court read the licensing rules as commercial regulation. The majority reads the constitutional text to reach the sale itself.

Ho's concurrence rejects the dissent's framing. Judge Oldham also wrote separately, joined by Ho, arguing that restricting sales infringes the right to keep and bear arms, since keeping an item includes acquiring it and disposing of it.

Why the concession matters

The government's position did a lot of the work here. With the Justice Department conceding that the Amendment covers commercial sales, the panel had no contested question about textual coverage to resolve. The fight now moves to history.

That is where the Bruen test puts the burden on the government. It must show that licensing dealers fits the tradition of American firearm regulation. The district court said it does, but it said so as an alternative holding and without the benefit of the Fifth Circuit's ruling on coverage.

Federal law has required dealers to be licensed for decades. Every prosecution under § 922(a)(1) in the Fifth Circuit now sits in a circuit where the text covers the conduct. Defendants charged in Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi can be expected to raise it.

The open questions are specific. The district court must apply the historical-tradition test to the licensing scheme. It must also decide what becomes of Deare's conviction and 97-month sentence. And the government has not said whether it will seek further review of a ruling it did not contest on the central point.

Sources used for this briefing

5 links from 5 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center-right
ReasonSecond Amendment as a Right to Sell Guns as Well as to Have and Buy Them?
right
BreitbartFifth Circuit Panel: Firearm Sales Are Protected by the Second Amendment
right
AmmoLandFifth Circuit Rules Second Amendment Protects Firearm Sales in Major Federal Gun Case
unknown
ammosightFifth Circuit Says the Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales and Sends a Louisiana Unlicensed-Dealing Conviction Back, 2-1
unknown
gunstuff.tvFifth Circuit Holds Second Amendment Covers Gun Sales