Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.
Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.
Epic Tells Supreme Court Apple's 27% Link Fee Defied Injunction; Solicitor General Says Fee Wasn't Clearly Barred

Epic Games told the Supreme Court on Friday, Nov. 13, that Apple was rightly held in contempt of a federal injunction. Epic says Apple answered the order by charging a 27% commission on web purchases and burying the links that were supposed to make those purchases possible.
Apple says the order never mentioned commissions, so it can't be punished for charging one.
The justices will hear the case on Jan. 11, 2027. Apple's final reply brief is due Dec. 14.
How the fight got here
Epic sued in 2020 after it activated its own payment system inside Fortnite and Apple pulled the game from the App Store. Epic lost most of its antitrust claims. But the 2021 injunction barred Apple from stopping developers from linking users to other payment options or telling users those options exist.
Apple then allowed external links, but with a commission of up to 27% on purchases made on the web within seven days of a link tap. It also added rules on how links and buttons could look.
In April 2025, District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers found Apple in willful violation of the injunction and barred it from collecting commissions on off-app purchases. The Ninth Circuit upheld the contempt finding but ruled that banning every possible external-purchase fee went too far. As described in the filings, Apple may eventually charge a limited amount covering costs genuinely necessary to support external links, but it can't charge a commission until the district court approves a fee.
Apple petitioned the Supreme Court in May. The Court took the case in June.
Epic's math
Epic's brief argues the 27% rate was built to fail. Apple's standard in-app cut runs as high as 30%. A developer sending users to a web payment provider would owe Apple 27% and separately pay more than 3% in processing costs, Epic says, which can exceed what Apple takes on its own system.
"As a result, developers actually would lose money by directing consumers to external payment systems," the filing states. Epic also cites an Apple executive who acknowledged that linked-out transactions would cost developers more than purchases processed through Apple at 30%.
Epic says Apple "reverse engineered" the rate, and that it was paired with a full-page warning before users could leave an app, limits on dynamic URLs, and approved wording for links. Epic also says Apple could not identify a single developer that sent customers to its own payment system and paid the 27% fee. That is Epic's account of the record.
A separate class-action complaint filed in May 2025 by Pure Sweat Basketball alleges that only 34 of 136,000 developers had applied for the link program as of May 2024. Those are allegations in a complaint, not findings.
Epic's legal theory leans on a 1949 Supreme Court decision, McComb v. Jacksonville Paper Co. In that case a company was held in contempt of a wage-and-hour decree even though its scheme wasn't specifically listed in the decree and wasn't willful. Epic reads McComb as a ban on workarounds that defeat an order's purpose. It says Apple "attempts to avoid contempt by proposing an extreme legal standard."
Tim Sweeney, Epic's CEO, has called the fee a "junk fee."
Apple's position
Apple's argument is about the limits of contempt, not about the fee's merits. In its brief, Apple says contempt is among the most potent powers a federal court has, and that for more than 140 years a party could be held in civil contempt only if there was no "fair ground of doubt" that it violated an order. That standard comes from Taggart v. Lorenzen.
Apple says the injunction's text did not mention commissions, a point it says the Ninth Circuit itself recognized. It also says Epic conceded the district court did not explicitly ban a new fee on purchases made outside an app. Courts, Apple argues, must enforce an injunction's letter, not its spirit.
The company says it "strongly and respectfully disagrees" with the district court's findings and put enormous resources into complying. Gregory Garre of Latham & Watkins represents Apple.
The government splits the difference
The Solicitor General's Sept. 21 brief supports neither company outright. It asks the justices to reverse the contempt finding as to the 27% commission, arguing the anti-steering ban "neither mentions nor covers commissions." On the fee, it says there is at least a fair ground of doubt that the injunction banned it.
The government does not give Apple a blank check. It says a commission could be so exorbitant that it works as a ban, and it names 300% as an example. On Apple's plain-buttons-only rule, it says there is no fair ground of doubt that the rule violated the injunction. It asks the Court to affirm on that point and send four other design restrictions back for reconsideration.
Both Apple and the government invoke the same "fair ground of doubt" test. Epic says the briefs differ mainly over the 27% rate.
Apple's side has outside support. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Chamber of Progress and several former federal antitrust enforcers filed supporting briefs.
What comes next
Epic has added Nicole Saharsky of Mayer Brown, who has argued 32 cases before the Supreme Court, to its longtime Cravath, Swaine & Moore team.
The question for the justices is narrower than the headlines suggest. It is how much room a company has to redesign its way around a court order. The Court could affirm contempt across the board, reverse it entirely, or do what the government proposes and split it by practice. The government's version would leave the plain-buttons violation in place and send the other design restrictions back to the lower courts for another look, while wiping out contempt for the 27% fee.
Apple's reply is due Dec. 14. Arguments follow on Jan. 11, 2027.
Sources used for this briefing
7 links from 7 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)
These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.