READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Only 23 of 321 California School Districts Produced Teacher Abuse Files Sought by Attorney John Manly, Breitbart Reports

Only 23 of 321 California School Districts Produced Teacher Abuse Files Sought by Attorney John Manly, Breitbart Reports
Attorney John Manly's firm sent Public Records Act requests to 321 California districts, and Breitbart News reports only 23 turned over files. Manly accuses the rest of hiding accused abusers, a charge the refusals alone do not prove. The U.S. Department of Education is already investigating California and about 20 districts nationwide over how they handle employees accused of abusing students.

Of 321 California school districts that received a Public Records Act request from the law firm of attorney John Manly, only 23 produced their files, according to an exclusive from Breitbart News based on its review of refusal letters and the documents that were released.

The records that did come out describe sexual abuse cases in those districts going back two decades, Breitbart reports.

That leaves nearly 300 districts that did not hand over the material.

What Manly is alleging

Manly is a California and New York attorney whose firm has represented plaintiffs in abuse cases against the Catholic Church, school districts and other institutions. He also represented victims of Jeffrey Epstein.

He did not soften his read of the refusals. "I think it says they're hiding pedophiles and accused pedophile teachers from the public," Manly told Breitbart. "They don't want the scandal. They cannot afford the truth."

That is Manly's characterization. A district declining a records request is not, on its own, a finding that any particular employee abused a student or that any district concealed one. No district-specific misconduct finding appears in the reported account.

Breitbart reports that many of the denials were written by the same elite law firms. That suggests a coordinated legal posture rather than 298 separate judgment calls. It does not say what the legal argument is.

The federal probe

The U.S. Department of Education has launched an investigation into California and roughly 20 districts across the country. Breitbart says California is essentially the center of that inquiry.

The probe grew out of a "Dear Colleague" letter that Education Secretary Linda McMahon sent to districts in August, which Breitbart obtained. The letter targets a practice known as "passing the trash." That is where a teacher, counselor or administrator caught in a sex scandal with a student is quietly moved to another school, or given a good reference to land a job in another district.

Both Manly's firm and McMahon have accused school administrators and teachers unions of the practice, according to Breitbart. Those are accusations. No findings from the federal investigation have been announced.

The practice, if it occurs as alleged, would run against state and federal law, which is why the records matter. Without personnel and complaint files, outsiders cannot check whether a district disclosed a problem or buried it.

A Virginia district in turmoil

Breitbart also points to a Virginia school district that it says closed its doors after a sex abuse scandal. According to its account, three administrators were arrested, and the superintendent, a principal and school board members resigned. More than 15 employees were put on leave.

Breitbart attributes the collapse to the district's failure to run proper background checks on more than 500 employees over three years. That case is a separate matter from the California records dispute, and the details come from Breitbart's reporting.

What remains unanswered

It is unclear why 298 districts did not produce what Manly asked for. The refusal letters presumably cite legal grounds, but the specific grounds have not been laid out publicly in the reporting. Districts that wish to defend the refusals can do so on the record. Few have.

Transparency over educator abuse is not a partisan issue. Parents send their kids to these buildings by law. Taxpayers fund the districts and the lawyers who write the denials, and nobody has said how much those firms are being paid to keep the files closed.

The next concrete step sits with the Department of Education. Its investigation of California and about 20 districts is open, and whether it compels the files Manly's firm could not get is the unresolved question. Manly's request also leaves the option of legal action over the refusals, though no such filing has been reported.

Sources used for this briefing

1 link from 1 independent newsroom (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

right
BreitbartExclusive: Hundreds of California Districts Refuse to Release Teacher Sex Abuse Files — ‘Hiding Pedophiles’