READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

MLBPA Rejects International Draft, Counters With Bigger Bonus Pools; MLB Drops High School Eligibility Change

MLBPA Rejects International Draft, Counters With Bigger Bonus Pools; MLB Drops High School Eligibility Change
Players turned down MLB's 12-round international draft at the Nov. 20 bargaining session in New York and offered a plan built on penalties for illegal pre-agreements and larger bonus pools. MLB withdrew its proposal to bar high schoolers from the domestic draft. The CBA expires Dec. 1, with the salary cap fight still unresolved and a lockout expected.

The Nov. 20 bargaining session in New York produced the first real movement on amateur talent rules. It was not movement toward a deal.

The Major League Baseball Players Association rejected the league's international amateur draft outright. The union instead proposed changes to the current signing system. MLB, for its part, gave up one domestic proposal.

What MLB gave up and what it kept

MLB withdrew its proposal that would have made high school players ineligible for the domestic amateur draft. League spokesperson Glen Caplin said the move came in recognition of "the feedback we received from the MLBPA." The league proposed keeping current entry rules for domestic amateurs.

The international draft stays on the table. MLB has sought one since 2001 and has been rebuffed repeatedly by players. In June it proposed a 12-round draft starting in 2027, with $200 million in signing bonus pools for 2027, roughly equal to 2026 international amateur spending. Management also proposed hard slots for each draft pick and asked that the minimum signing age for international amateurs be raised to 18 from 17 on Sept. 1 of their signing year.

ClutchPoints reported that the league's plan would run 360 selections.

"On the international system, we continue to believe it is long past time to reform the system in ways that would address longstanding challenges and benefit future players," Caplin said. "The enhanced transparency of the International Draft that we have proposed best addresses the root causes of corruption in the current system."

The union's counter

Interim executive director Bruce Meyer said the union wants a system that "preserves opportunities for future generations of players, protects young prospects from exploitation, and provides flexibility without further burdening international players with new artificial restrictions like a draft."

The union's plan goes after the corruption problem directly. Players outside the U.S. are eligible to sign as young as 16, but it is common for players, their families and trainers to strike handshake deals with teams at 13 or 14. Those deals are the target.

Under the union proposal, a team that enters into an agreement with an international amateur before a signing period opens would:

  • lose the right to sign that player
  • forfeit pool space equal to the agreed-upon signing bonus
  • lose its entire pool space in the subsequent signing period
  • face a minimum $200,000 fine

The lost pool space would be redistributed to other clubs. The sides would also hire a joint compliance officer.

Money and small markets

The proposal also asks for more money. The union wants the three basic team pool levels in 2027 raised from $8,034,900 to $8.5 million, from $7,357,100 to $7.75 million and from $6,679,200 to $7 million, with the figures growing in future years at the same rate as industry revenue. The union also wants the signing bonus pool exemption raised from $10,000 to $75,000 to lift bonuses at the low end, plus new bonuses as players move up through the minors.

Teams would be allowed to exceed their pools but would be taxed on the overage, and a team 15% or more over could lose future pool amounts. The union's plan would also make it easier for teams to trade pool space and roll over unused space at the end of a signing period.

For small-market clubs, the union proposed:

  • an extra $1 million in pool money during a single signing period of the five-year deal
  • an extra $500,000 in each signing period following a postseason appearance
  • a financial reward for reaching the postseason, funded by tax revenue from teams that exceed their pools
  • more pool space as a reward for having lost or signed free agents (or soon-to-be free agents)

The union also wants separate, independent pools for players with limited foreign professional experience, so they would not compete for money with teenage prospects. The Dodgers' signing of Roki Sasaki before the 2025 season is the example of the current problem.

The two arguments

The disagreement is over method. MLB says a draft is the way to end the handshake-deal culture, because transparency addresses the root causes of corruption. The union says penalties and enforcement can fix the abuse without restricting players' freedom to negotiate with teams. Neither side has conceded the other's premise.

The proposals also differ on spending. The league's offer holds 2027 pools near current spending levels. The union wants pools raised across the board.

The clock

The five-year CBA expires at 11:59 p.m. EST on Dec. 1. Management is expected to lock players out immediately, which would be the sport's 10th work stoppage since 1972.

Owners are pushing for a salary cap. Players say they never will agree to one. That fight, not the amateur system, is what threatens the 2027 season.

MLB.com reported that the two sides are expected to meet again Monday. The amateur rules are the area where movement occurred Friday, with the league's withdrawal of the high school change as its concession.

Sources used for this briefing

7 links from 6 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center-left
sports.yahooMLBPA rejects international draft proposal in latest volley in CBA fight
right
NY PostMLBPA rejects international draft proposal in latest volley in CBA fight
unknown
Advertiser TribunePlayers reject MLB's international draft proposal; ask for higher bonus pools, aid to small markets
unknown
ClutchPointsMLB rumors: MLBPA suggests international draft in latest CBA proposal, but is league interested?
unknown
mlbplayersMLBPA Makes International Amateur Signing Proposal
unknown
JingletreeMLBPA rejects international draft proposal in latest volley in CBA fight
unknown
MLB.comMLB offers concession on domestic draft; MLBPA makes proposal on international players