READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Boycott Calls Sandpaper Scandal Bigger Than Cronje as Cummins Stands by Denial After Bancroft Account

Boycott Calls Sandpaper Scandal Bigger Than Cronje as Cummins Stands by Denial After Bancroft Account
Geoffrey Boycott wrote in The Telegraph that the 2018 ball-tampering scandal was bigger than Hansie Cronje's match-fixing and that Steve Smith and David Warner deserved five-year bans. Cameron Bancroft's 4,000-word account says Australia's bowlers gave him feedback on his work on the ball, and Pat Cummins' camp says his position has not changed in eight years. Cummins' future as Test captain is in doubt, and Darren Lehmann has said he will take time to work through the allegations against him.

Since Usman Khawaja's autobiography Sabr reopened the 2018 Cape Town ball-tampering affair earlier this month, the story has moved from one player's claim that "all of us" were to blame to a direct dispute over who in the Australian camp knew what.

The latest salvo came Saturday, Nov. 21, from Geoffrey Boycott.

Boycott's verdict

In his column for The Telegraph, the former England opener wrote that the sandpaper scandal is "even bigger than Hansie Cronje's match-fixing, which ripped apart South Africa cricket more than 25 years ago."

His reasoning is scale. "This is bigger than anything I have read or seen in cricket: a whole team cheating," Boycott wrote. He argued that Cronje's scheme mainly involved recruiting two junior players, Herschelle Gibbs and Henry Williams, while "the rest of the squad and coaches had no idea."

Of the Australian side, he wrote: "The squad and coaches were all up to their necks in it, plotting and planning to cheat en masse, and the cover-up let three players take the blame."

Boycott also went after Smith personally. The then captain was present when Warner floated using abrasive material to get reverse swing and when Bancroft agreed to carry it out. Smith told the group he did not want to know more.

"As captain, Smith should have put a stop to it as soon as Warner raised the idea of using sandpaper," Boycott wrote. "History should not be kind to Smith. He abrogated his responsibility as a captain."

He added that he has always believed Smith and Warner "got off lightly" and should have been banned for five years each.

For the record, Smith and Warner each served 12-month bans from Cricket Australia. Bancroft, who used the sandpaper on the ball, got nine months. All three returned in 2019.

Bancroft's account and Cummins' answer

The more consequential development is Bancroft's. He wrote a 4,000-word first-person statement after Cummins, at a 68-minute press conference, denied any knowledge of sandpaper being taken onto the field in Cape Town.

Bancroft wrote that Cummins' comments left him feeling "betrayed and alone." He alleged that the bowlers gave him feedback: "Is it going yet? It's not going yet, it needs more. So I would use the sandpaper more on the ball."

He also alleged that then head coach Darren Lehmann and bowling coach David Saker were part of conversations about getting the ball to reverse swing, because shining it and using saliva "weren't cutting it." These are Bancroft's allegations. Lehmann, now an ABC radio commentator, said he would take time to work through each one.

Warner backed Bancroft in an interview with Seven News. "Obviously, he's told the truth," Warner said. "I think it's been weighing on him heavily for a long time." Chadd Sayers has also backed Khawaja's claims.

Cummins' side is not budging. His management said Bancroft's statement contained "nothing that hasn't been answered by Pat in his press conference." His manager, Neil Maxwell, went further.

"Pat's position hasn't changed in eight years. He's been consistent and adamant from day one," Maxwell said. "Pat feels for Cam of course. He has been through a lot." Maxwell added: "Pat has rebuilt the Australian cricket team. That 24-year-old in Cape Town resolved to fix the team and spent eight years doing it."

That is a flat denial against a named, first-person allegation. Cummins says he knew nothing. Bancroft says the bowlers were giving him notes on how the sandpaper was working. Both cannot be right, and no independent evidence has been presented in either direction.

Hazlewood draws a line

Josh Hazlewood, who like Cummins denies knowing about the tampering, publicly backed his captain ahead of the Test series against New Zealand. He spoke to News Corp on Saturday, Nov. 21.

"To get the group where it is now and in a position where something like that is never going to happen again, I think is just a remarkable job. He's a great leader," Hazlewood said.

Asked whether he would walk away if Cricket Australia acted against Cummins, he said: "I think I'd have to be put in that position to make a decision, but you'd have to think about it, yeah."

That is a hypothetical, not a threat. It does show how far the dispute could reach if Cricket Australia moves against its current captain in the middle of a home season.

The fallout so far

Bancroft's allegations have put Cummins' future as Test captain in doubt. Of those who have backed Khawaja's version, only Bancroft is still playing. Warner and Sayers have retired. Khawaja and Warner have also reportedly been kept off television commentary during the storm.

Boycott's column also revives an old argument. Smith has accepted responsibility, and Khawaja writes that Smith took his ban partly to shield teammates. Boycott's position is that a captain who says "I don't want to know" and then accepts the benefit of the cheating has not escaped responsibility.

Cricket Australia's 2018 investigation ended with three players punished. Khawaja, Warner, Bancroft and Sayers now say others knew. Cummins and Hazlewood say they did not.

The open questions are specific. Lehmann has yet to answer Bancroft's allegations about him and Saker. Cricket Australia has not said whether it will reopen its inquiry. Cummins is due to lead Australia against New Zealand with his captaincy under this cloud.

Sources used for this briefing

7 links from 7 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center-left
sports.yahoo'Bigger than Hansie Cronje's match-fixing': Legendary cricketer makes explosive Sandpaper Gate claim
center-right
Times of India'Bigger than match-fixing': Legendary cricketer's explosive Sandpaper Gate claim
left
The GuardianPat Cummins stands by ‘consistent’ sandpaper position after Cameron Bancroft’s claims
right
News18'History Should NOT Be Kind To Steve Smith': Cricket Legend Lashes Out
right
Times NowBigger Than Cronje's Scandal; Smith, Warner Should Have Been Banned For 5 Years: Boycott
unknown
Press News Agency‘Bigger than Hansie Cronje’s match-fixing’: Legendary cricketer makes explosive Sandpaper Gate claim
unknown
CricktrackerBoycott slams Steven Smith over 2018 sandpaper scandal