How to read war and conflict reporting: combatant claims, casualty counts and unverified footage
War reporting rests on three kinds of material that are hard to confirm at the time: claims made by the parties fighting, casualty numbers, and video or photos from the scene. Published standards treat each differently. Disputed claims are attributed to who made them, casualty figures depend on how they were counted, and footage is examined for who filmed it, where and when before it is relied on.
Claims by the parties to a conflict
The AP's standards say that "anything in the AP news report that could reasonably be disputed should be attributed," with enough detail to identify the source and explain why that source is credible [4]. The BBC's guidelines say content that "cannot be corroborated should normally be attributed," and that producers should be "honest and open about what they don't know" [3]. In practice, a sentence such as "the ministry said" is different from a sentence stating the same thing as established fact. The first records a claim; the second asserts it.
The BBC also advises caution with material supplied by outside parties that may have a stake in the outcome, noting that such material "may be inaccurate" and that the BBC "cannot vouch for the circumstances in which it was produced" [3].
How casualty counts are produced
A casualty number is the output of a method, and methods differ. The UN human rights office (OHCHR) publishes its method in its Guidance on Casualty Recording. Information "must draw on multiple independent sources," and the aim is to corroborate each piece of information with concurring information from two additional independent and reliable sources. Where that is not possible, a reliable primary source may need corroboration from one additional independent source [1].
The same guidance warns about circular reporting: when information reported by several sources "can be traced to a single source," for example several media carrying a story that originated with one agency [1]. Two reports repeating one origin are one source, not two.
The guidance also explains why published totals can be incomplete or provisional. It says gathering and verifying information, access and security concerns can make it impossible to identify each victim, determine their status at the time, or attribute responsibility [1]. It adds that in armed conflict settings, where access to verified information is more challenging, the terms used to describe casualties "are likely to reflect a factual description rather than constitute a legal determination" [1].
The BBC's guidelines apply a general rule to any figure: numbers "should not necessarily be taken at face value," and should be explained, put in context and attributed, "with important caveats and limitations explained" [3]. A count from a combatant, a hospital system, a monitoring body and a government may each follow a different definition and a different level of proof. The standards call for saying which one is being reported.
How footage is examined
The Berkeley Protocol on Digital Open Source Investigations, published by OHCHR with the UC Berkeley Human Rights Center, describes verification as having three considerations: the source, the digital item or file, and the content, "which should be looked at collectively and compared for consistency" [2]. Its named techniques include:
- Source analysis: assessing a source's credibility and reliability, including connections to parties to a conflict and the source's motivations or interests [2].
- Provenance: establishing origin. The protocol prefers "first copy found online" to "first copy online," because the original may have been removed [2].
- Geolocation: identifying or estimating where an item was recorded, for example by matching unique geographic features to a map [2].
- Chronolocation: corroborating dates and times shown in imagery, for example from the length of shadows together with other indicators [2].
- Completeness: an incomplete clip may still be useful, but the gaps affect how much weight it can carry [2].
The protocol lists circular reporting, decontextualization and misinterpretation among the issues that affect the validity of online material [2]. The BBC guidelines say user-generated material should not be assumed accurate, "may need to be verified," "should always be clearly identified," and "may not provide a complete picture" [3]. AP's standards require that file, library or archive photos and video be identified as such [4].
What the standards ask of a report
- Is each disputed claim attributed to a named party or source [3][4]?
- Is it stated who produced a casualty figure and how it was counted [1][3]?
- Is footage labelled as user-generated or archive, with what is and is not confirmed about it [3][4]?
- Are corrections made quickly, clearly and appropriately [3]?
How Unbiased Headlines handles this
Unbiased Headlines' method page says it works from real source text only, that a fact verification gate checks claims back against the underlying sources, and that claims that cannot be verified are softened or cut [5]. Its sources page lists the news sources it monitors [7], and its why page says articles link back to the sources behind them [6]. Full details: unbiasedheadlines.com/method, unbiasedheadlines.com/why, unbiasedheadlines.com/sources.
FAQ
Why do casualty figures change over time?
Recording systems corroborate information from multiple independent sources, and gathering and verifying it can be limited by access and security [1]. The count reflects what has been confirmed under the method used.
What is circular reporting?
It is when information appearing in several places traces back to one source, such as several outlets carrying a story from a single agency [1][2].
What do geolocation and chronolocation mean?
Geolocation identifies where an image or video was recorded; chronolocation corroborates when [2].
Does unverified footage mean false footage?
No. Standards say such material "may need to be verified" and should be identified as user-generated [3]; the Berkeley Protocol notes that an incomplete clip can still carry evidential weight, depending on the gaps [2].
Sources
- OHCHR, "Guidance on Casualty Recording" (HR/PUB/19/1, 2019). https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Publications/Guidance_on_Casualty_Recording.pdf (read 2026-11-19)
- OHCHR and UC Berkeley Human Rights Center, "Berkeley Protocol on Digital Open Source Investigations" (HR/PUB/20/2), chapter VI.E-F. https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/2024-01/OHCHR_BerkeleyProtocol.pdf (read 2026-11-19)
- BBC Editorial Guidelines, "Section 3: Accuracy" (principles 3.2; guidelines 3.4). https://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidelines/accuracy (read 2026-11-19)
- The Associated Press, "News values and principles: Telling the story." https://www.ap.org/about/news-values-and-principles/telling-the-story/ (read 2026-11-19)
- Unbiased Headlines, "Our Editorial Method." https://unbiasedheadlines.com/method (read 2026-11-19)
- Unbiased Headlines, "Why Unbiased Headlines." https://unbiasedheadlines.com/why (read 2026-11-19)
- Unbiased Headlines, "Source Transparency." https://unbiasedheadlines.com/sources (read 2026-11-19)