How to check a claim: attribution, primary documents and what "officials said" means
A claim in a news story can be checked by asking who said it, how that person knows, and where the underlying document is. Published newsroom standards say that anything reasonably disputed should be attributed, that a source should be described so the audience can judge it, and that a story should say when a quote comes from a written document. "Officials said" is attribution to a group of people by description; it is a different thing from a named, on-the-record statement or a published document.
Three kinds of attribution
Newsroom standards separate sourcing into levels. The Associated Press defines "on the record" as information that can be used with no caveats, quoting the source by name. It defines "background" as information that can be published only under conditions negotiated with the source, generally a description of the source's position instead of a name. "Deep background" is information used without attribution to the source [1].
The BBC's accuracy guidelines say a named, on-the-record source is always preferable when a single source is relied on, and that sources "should normally be identified and their credentials made clear so that audiences can judge their status" [2].
What "officials said" can and cannot tell a reader
A phrase such as "officials said" or "a senior official said" is a description, not a name. AP's standard says simply quoting "a source" is not allowed, and that the description should be as specific as possible, with examples such as "a senior official in the British Foreign Office" [1]. The same standard lists conditions for anonymous material: it must be information and not opinion or speculation, it must not be available except under anonymity, and the source must be reliable and in a position to have direct knowledge. The story must also explain why anonymity was granted [1].
The BBC guidelines add that when anonymity is agreed, the audience should get whatever information can be given about the source, "in a way that does not materially mislead about the source's status" [2]. Both standards also say a manager or senior editor can be told the source's identity [1][2].
These points show what is and is not stated in the text. An illustration, invented for this guide: "Officials said the plan will begin next month." The sentence gives no name, no office and no document. A sentence reading "According to a memo dated March 3 from the Department of Example, the plan begins April 1" names a document that can be located.
Primary documents: three common types
BBC guidelines say information, facts, documents and digital material must be checked and verified, and that producers who cannot verify material should usually say so and attribute the information [2]. AP says that if a story hinges on documents, the reporter must describe how they were obtained, to the extent possible [1]. A primary document is the original record, as opposed to a description of it. Three types appear often:
- Court filings and opinions. Federal case files are available through the Public Access to Court Electronic Records (PACER) service, which allows anyone with an account to search for case and docket information [3]. The U.S. Supreme Court posts its opinions on its website when they are released [4].
- Federal Register notices. The Federal Register is the daily journal of the federal government, published every business day by the National Archives' Office of the Federal Register. Each issue has four categories: presidential documents, rules and regulations, proposed rules, and notices such as scheduled public hearings and meetings [5].
- Agency releases. Government agencies publish their own announcements on their own websites; NASA's news listing is one example [6]. A release is the agency's own account. AP's standard says news releases cannot be published in their original form, and that the material's credibility must be judged and augmented with information from other sources [1]. The BBC guidelines list government agencies among outside parties whose supplied material may have vested interests, and require such material to be clearly labelled with who supplied it [2].
Questions a claim can be put through
- Who is the source? Named, described, or not identified at all [1][2].
- Is there a document? If a quote comes from a report, email or news release, the standard is that the story says so [1].
- Is anyone else cited? AP routinely seeks and requires more than one source when sourcing is anonymous [1]; the BBC says producers should be reluctant to rely on a single source [2].
- Could it be disputed? Material that could reasonably be disputed should be attributed [1].
- Is a statistic explained? The BBC says numbers should be explained, put in context and attributed, with caveats and limitations stated [2].
How Unbiased Headlines handles claims
The Unbiased Headlines method page states that stories are written from real source text, that a fact verification gate checks claims back against the underlying sources, and that claims that cannot be verified are softened or cut. It also says articles link to their sources [7]. The why page says 100% of articles link back to the sources behind them [8]. The sources page lists the news sources monitored [9].
Full details are on unbiasedheadlines.com/method, unbiasedheadlines.com/why and unbiasedheadlines.com/sources.
FAQ
What does "officials said" mean?
It attributes information to people described by role, without names. Newsroom standards say such descriptions should be as specific as possible and that the reason for anonymity should be explained [1][2].
What is a primary document?
The original record, such as a court filing, a Federal Register notice or an agency release, as opposed to a report about it [3][5][6].
Where are federal court records kept?
Federal case files are maintained electronically and available through PACER; many opinions are also available without fee through GovInfo [3].
Why do standards say a document's origin should be described?
AP says that when a story hinges on documents, the reporter must describe how they were obtained, at least to the extent possible [1].
Sources
- The Associated Press, "News values and principles: Telling the story." https://www.ap.org/about/news-values-and-principles/telling-the-story/ (read 2026-11-19)
- BBC Editorial Guidelines, "Section 3: Accuracy – Guidelines." https://www.bbc.co.uk/editorialguidelines/guidelines/accuracy/guidelines (read 2026-11-19)
- U.S. Courts, "Find a Case (PACER)." https://www.uscourts.gov/court-records/find-a-case-pacer (read 2026-11-19)
- Supreme Court of the United States, "Opinions of the Court." https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/slipopinion/25 (read 2026-11-19)
- National Archives, "About the Federal Register." https://www.archives.gov/federal-register/the-federal-register/about.html (read 2026-11-19)
- NASA, "All NASA News." https://www.nasa.gov/news/all-news/ (read 2026-11-19)
- Unbiased Headlines, "Our Editorial Method." https://unbiasedheadlines.com/method (read 2026-11-19)
- Unbiased Headlines, "Why Unbiased Headlines." https://unbiasedheadlines.com/why (read 2026-11-19)
- Unbiased Headlines, "Source Transparency." https://unbiasedheadlines.com/sources (read 2026-11-19)