READ. SCROLL. LISTEN.

Unbiased headlines. Facts, not spin.

Unbiased Headlines is an independently owned news organization. We bring you the facts, not opinions, written fresh from 110+ named sources. Sources linked so you can verify it yourself.

← Back to headlines

Coinkite CEO Says Coldcard Flaw Hit 0.17% of Users. Galaxy Research Estimates 1,830 BTC Stolen

Coinkite CEO Says Coldcard Flaw Hit 0.17% of Users. Galaxy Research Estimates 1,830 BTC Stolen
Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak says a firmware flaw in Coldcard hardware wallets affected about 0.17% of users, but the company has not disclosed how many users or devices that figure is measured against. Galaxy Research estimates roughly 1,830 BTC, about $116 million at the time, was drained from around 9,200 addresses. A patch cannot repair seeds that were already generated badly, so exposed funds stay at risk until owners move them.

Coinkite CEO Rodolfo Novak says a firmware flaw in Coldcard hardware wallets hit about 0.17% of the company's users. He first floated 0.2% before settling on the lower number.

The blockchain tells a different story. Galaxy Research estimates attackers stole approximately 1,830 BTC, worth about $116 million at the time, from roughly 9,200 addresses.

What went wrong

The problem traces to firmware versions 4.0.0 and 4.0.1, which shipped in March 2021. Under certain conditions, devices running them fell back on a weak software pseudorandom number generator when creating seeds.

That produced seeds with sharply reduced entropy. Less unpredictability means a smaller pool of possible seed phrases, and a small enough pool can be searched.

Attackers could reconstruct affected seed phrases offline. They did not need to touch the device or trick the owner.

The timeline

Galaxy Research tracked the draining from July 30, 2026 through August 4, 2026. Coinkite began releasing emergency firmware patches on July 31, one day after the theft started.

A class action was filed in Ontario on September 11, 2026, against Coinkite, Novak and co-founder Peter Gray. The suit alleges the company failed to adequately warn users despite internal notifications about the issue.

Those are allegations in a filing. None has been tested in court.

The patch does not fix old seeds

Updating the firmware stops a device from generating weak seeds going forward. It does nothing for a seed that already exists.

Anyone holding a seed created on affected firmware has to generate a new one and move the funds. A firmware update alone leaves the old, guessable seed in place. Reporting from Siam Blockchain puts the exposure window for seeds between March 2021 and the July 2026 patches.

The 0.17% figure

Novak says the number comes from loss reports, public blockchain data and internal production figures. Coinkite has not published total sales or a user count, so nobody outside the company can check the percentage or convert it into a number of affected people.

There is a built-in limit on any precise count. Coinkite designs its products around privacy and does not track who owns what or how much sits in each wallet.

Production figures also count devices, not people. A single owner may have bought several Coldcards or spread coins across many addresses, so 0.17% of units, 0.17% of users and 9,200 drained addresses are three different measurements.

Novak's framing is that the share of affected users is small. Galaxy's tally of coins and addresses measures the damage in a different way, and it is the only independent count of what left the wallets.

Galaxy's dollar figure is not new. It dates to the August and September tracking of the thefts. The new item on November 18 is the CEO's percentage.

Silence on compensation and leadership

After giving the number, Novak posted that "Bitcoin won," that his work in the industry was finished and that he would step back. He then set his X account to private. He did not say whether he is leaving the CEO role.

Coinkite has been helping trace the stolen funds with law enforcement, according to Siam Blockchain's reporting. The company has not announced compensation for victims. The Ontario court will decide whether the failure-to-warn claims against the company and its executives proceed.

Victims still lack practical answers. Coinkite has not said how many devices were sold in the affected firmware range or whether it will make anyone whole.

Sources used for this briefing

6 links from 6 independent newsrooms (syndicated copies of the same report count once)

These are the sources it draws on, linked so you can verify.

center
Crypto BriefingCoinkite CEO says Coldcard flaw hit 0.17% of users as Galaxy tallies $116M in stolen Bitcoin
center-left
NPRBlockchain intelligence firms link North Korea to $6.3B hack on Binance
right
Epoch TimesWebsites Compromised in Bid to Steal Crypto: Researcher
right
Fox NewsKurt Knutsson, CyberGuy Report | Fox News
unknown
CryptoNewsCoinkite CEO says Coldcard flaw hit 0.17% of users as Galaxy tallies $116M in stolen Bitcoin
unknown
siamblockchainCEO Coinkite อ้างช่องโหว่ Coldcard กระทบผู้ใช้ไม่ถึง 0.2% แต่ Galaxy ประเมิน Bitcoin ถูกขโมยราว $116 ล้าน